Florida set for record 20th execution of 2026 as Thomas Overton faces lethal injection Thursday for Keys double murder

Florida is scheduled to execute Thomas Mitchell Overton at 6 p.m. Thursday, Nov. 19, at Florida State Prison for the 1991 killings of Michael and Missy MacIvor in their Tavernier home in the Florida Keys. If the lethal injection goes forward, it will be the 20th execution in Florida this year, breaking the record of 19 the state set in 2025, the most in a single year since the U.S. Supreme Court allowed executions to resume in 1976.
Gov. Ron DeSantis signed Overton's death warrant on Oct. 21, one day after the state executed William Reaves for the 1980s killing of Indian River County Sheriff's Deputy Richard Raczkowski. Overton, 70, was sentenced to death in 1999. On Friday, Nov. 13, the Florida Supreme Court rejected his final round of state appeals and refused to stay the execution.
The Florida Supreme Court ruling
In the case docketed as SC2026-1724, the justices affirmed a circuit judge's summary denial of Overton's latest postconviction motion, his third successive one, and denied his petition for a writ of habeas corpus along with his request for a stay. According to the opinion, the court found the lower court did not abuse its discretion in denying his public records demands, which it said were not tied to a legally cognizable claim. The justices also held that his challenge to Florida's clemency and death warrant process was not a cognizable claim, and they rejected his claim of actual innocence, concluding that it repackaged earlier attacks on the strength of the state's trial evidence rather than presenting newly discovered evidence.
The court issued its mandate immediately and barred motions for rehearing, leaving the federal courts as the only remaining venue. The U.S. Supreme Court had already turned away an earlier Overton petition for review on Feb. 23, 2026, according to its docket. No ruling on any new federal filing had been reported as of Monday.
The killings in Tavernier
Michael MacIvor, 30, and his wife, Missy MacIvor, 29, a local teacher who was eight months pregnant, were killed in their Tavernier home in August 1991. Some news accounts have dated the killings to 1992, but the Florida Supreme Court's own case summary from Overton's direct appeal places them in 1991. The couple's unborn son did not survive.
According to the facts recounted in court records and summarized by the News Service of Florida, Overton broke into the home, struck Michael MacIvor on the back of the head with a blunt object, kicked him and strangled him. Missy MacIvor was bound, raped and strangled. Overton, then 35, had worked as a clerk at an Amoco service station in Tavernier, where he had met Missy MacIvor, the Palm Beach Post reported.
A jailhouse informant, James Zientek, testified at trial that Overton told him he broke in intending to rape a woman and killed the couple to muddle the crime scene. The trial judge's sentencing order described what it called a carefully conceived plan to avoid detection and arrest. CBS Miami reported that, according to court documents, the intruder wore what was described as a ninja-type suit.
How DNA broke the case
The case went unsolved for years. In 1996, while Overton was in custody on an unrelated burglary charge, he cut himself, and investigators used his blood to develop a DNA profile, according to the Florida Supreme Court's summary of the case. Separate DNA tests in 1996 and 1998 matched evidence taken from bedding in the MacIvor home, the News Service of Florida reported.
Overton was convicted in 1999. Jurors recommended death by votes of 8 to 4 for Michael MacIvor's murder and 9 to 3 for Missy MacIvor's, according to the court summary. The judge imposed two death sentences, plus life terms for sexual battery and burglary of a dwelling and 15 years for the death of the unborn child. The Florida Supreme Court upheld the convictions and death sentences on direct appeal in 2001.
Overton has long maintained he is innocent. Over the years his appeals pointed to strands of dark hair found on the tape used to bind Missy MacIvor that did not match Overton or the victims, and sought further DNA testing; those requests were denied, the Palm Beach Post reported. The jury's death recommendations in his case were not unanimous. Since 2023, Florida law has allowed a death sentence on the recommendation of at least eight of 12 jurors.
The family waiting in the Keys
Sharon MacIvor, Michael MacIvor's sister, plans to witness the execution on behalf of her parents, who died before the warrant was signed, CBS Miami reported. She told the station she wants to give her parents a voice for the loss they carried. "It helps in the sense that at this point our families will have closure," she said.
A record year for Florida executions
Florida carried out 19 executions in 2025, the most in a single year since 1976. It matched that total this year on Nov. 5, when it executed Jesse Guardado for the 2004 killing of Jackie Malone, a 75-year-old Walton County woman who had helped him find housing and a job after his release from prison. Overton would push the state past its own record.
The pace has made Florida the national leader. The Death Penalty Information Center counted 32 executions in six states nationwide as of early November, with Texas next behind Florida at seven, according to the News Service of Florida. Under DeSantis, Florida has executed more people since 2025 than the rest of the country combined, the Palm Beach Post reported.
The governor has not signed every warrant through to the end. In October he withdrew the death warrant for William Thompson after psychiatrists evaluated Thompson for dementia and mental disability, the first time DeSantis had called off a scheduled execution.
Two more executions are already scheduled after Overton's, according to the governor's warrants as reported by the News Service of Florida and the Sarasota Herald-Tribune:
| Date | Inmate | Case | Count for 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nov. 19 | Thomas Overton | 1991 killings of Michael and Missy MacIvor, Tavernier | 20th |
| Dec. 1 | Ricardo Gonzalez | 1992 killing of North Miami Beach Officer Steven Bauer | 21st |
| Dec. 10 | Willie Seth Crain Jr. | Killing of a 7-year-old girl | 22nd |
What's next
Overton is set to die by lethal injection at Florida State Prison near Raiford, about 45 miles southwest of Jacksonville, at 6 p.m. Thursday unless a court or the governor intervenes. Florida's next scheduled execution after Thursday is Gonzalez's on Dec. 1.
Spotted an issue with this article?
Have something to say about this story?
Write us a letterComments
No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.
Related Coverage

Osceola deputy fatally shoots woman the sheriff says pointed a gun at a man outside an Old Town Kissimmee bar
5h ago

Accused gunman Henry Tenon due in court in Jared Bridegan murder case days after former landlord gets life sentence
12h ago

Lake City Daycare Worker Sentenced to 20 Years in Prison After Infant Suffered Skull Fracture and Brain Bleeding
1d ago

Cybertruck Driver Gets 6.5 Years in Prison for Deadly 97 mph DUI Crash That Killed Mother of Two in Miami-Dade
1d ago