Kyle McCord's First Start Falls Short as Missed Kicks Sink Dolphins 24-22 at Colts, Dropping Miami to 1-8

Kyle McCord ran for a touchdown in his first NFL start, but the Miami Dolphins missed two field goals and an extra point and lost 24-22 to the Indianapolis Colts on Sunday at Lucas Oil Stadium. The loss was Miami's third straight and dropped the Dolphins to 1-8, last in the AFC East, while the Colts (3-7) snapped a five-game losing streak.
Kicker Zane Gonzalez, promoted from the practice squad on Friday, went 1 of 3 on field goals, missing wide left from 47 and 51 yards, and also missed an extra point. The 51-yard miss in the fourth quarter would have given Miami the lead.
Seven points left on the field
Coach Jeff Hafley put the loss plainly afterward. "We've got to make the extra point, and we've got to make the field goal," Hafley said, according to the Associated Press. "It's 24-22, we miss an extra point, which forces us to go for 2, and we miss two field goals, that's seven points. We have to make those."
The misses came at three key moments. Miami's first scoring chance ended with the 47-yard try going wide left in the first quarter of a scoreless game. In the third quarter, after cornerback Chris Johnson returned an interception 59 yards for a touchdown, Gonzalez's extra point failed, leaving Miami behind 21-16 instead of 21-17. That forced the Dolphins to try a 2-point conversion after McCord's touchdown on the first play of the fourth quarter, and A.J. Haulcy broke up McCord's pass to keep Indianapolis ahead 24-22.
Miami's next possession reached the Indianapolis 33 before the 51-yarder sailed wide left with 9:49 remaining. Gonzalez did make a season-long 53-yard field goal in the third quarter. He had been promoted after making 5 of 7 field goals and all five of his extra-point attempts over the previous three games, the AP reported.
The Dolphins had two more chances. They punted after a drive that began at their own 9 midway through the fourth quarter, then got the ball back at their 42 with 3:15 left. That drive stalled when CJ Allen sacked McCord at the Indianapolis 49, and a fourth-down pass fell incomplete with 1:36 remaining. Seth McGowan's run for a first down on the Colts' ensuing possession let Indianapolis run out the clock.
McCord's debut
McCord started in place of Malik Willis, whom the Dolphins placed on injured reserve on Nov. 10 with a groin injury. He completed 17 of 32 passes for 209 yards with no touchdowns and no interceptions, was sacked three times and lost one fumble, and scored on a 3-yard run up the middle. The AP described it as a solid starting debut.
The costliest mistake came on Miami's first play of the second half. Starting at their own 10, the Dolphins lost the ball when Colts cornerback Justin Walley stripped McCord near the goal line and Adetomiwa Adebawore recovered in the end zone for a touchdown and a 21-7 lead.
McCord answered with a 31-yard completion to Malik Washington that set up the 53-yard field goal, and on Miami's touchdown drive he hit receiver Caleb Douglas for 38 yards to reach the Colts' 10. Douglas led Miami with three catches for 71 yards, and Ollie Gordon II ran 20 times for 76 yards.
McCord is a second-year player who was a sixth-round pick of the Philadelphia Eagles in 2025, after leading the FBS with 4,779 passing yards as a senior at Syracuse and going 11-1 as a starter at Ohio State in 2023, according to ESPN. Miami traded for him from the Green Bay Packers in August after he led the NFL in passing touchdowns during the preseason. Hafley said last week that the Dolphins still view Willis as their starter when he is healthy.
A trick play and a missed chance
Miami's offense found the end zone in the first half only on a trick play. After McGowan's 4-yard run gave the Colts a 7-0 lead early in the second quarter, McCord flipped the ball to Malik Washington, who threw a 34-yard touchdown pass to Jalen Tolbert to tie the game, according to the Dolphins' team recap.
Rookie safety Michael Taaffe then intercepted Daniel Jones, but the Dolphins could not cash in. Their drive reached the Indianapolis 8 before a fourth-down pass fell incomplete. The Colts answered with a nine-play, 92-yard drive that ended with Jones' 7-yard touchdown pass to Laquon Treadwell with 39 seconds left in the half.
Bright spots on defense
The defense gave Miami a chance. Johnson's pick-six, on a pass tipped into his hands, was the Dolphins' first interception return touchdown since December 2023, ending a 46-game stretch without one. Taaffe's interception was his third of the season, making him the first Dolphins rookie with three interceptions since Vontae Davis in 2009, according to the team.
Linebacker Jordyn Brooks led Miami with nine tackles, and edge rusher Chop Robinson recorded the team's only sack. Jones finished 11 of 22 for 108 yards with one touchdown and two interceptions, and was booed in the second half, the AP reported. The Colts still ran for 172 yards, with Jonathan Taylor gaining 83 on 16 carries and McGowan 77 on 12.
Indianapolis also committed 13 penalties for 83 yards, several of which kept the Colts from putting the game away sooner, according to the AP.
Injuries pile up
Miami played without center Aaron Brewer, who was in the concussion protocol, and lost defensive tackle Zeek Biggers to a knee injury in the first half. Backup center Andrew Meyer left late with a stinger but returned.
The Dolphins were already without defensive tackle Zach Sieler, a captain who is out for the season with a ruptured biceps suffered against Detroit, and running back De'Von Achane, who tore his ACL in Week 3, ESPN reported.
Where Miami's season stands
The Dolphins' lone win remains a 28-25 victory over the New York Jets on Oct. 25. Their recent results, according to ESPN:
| Date | Opponent | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Oct. 25 | at N.Y. Jets | W 28-25 |
| Nov. 1 | New England | L 24-19 |
| Nov. 8 | Detroit | L 19-9 |
| Nov. 15 | at Indianapolis | L 24-22 |
All three losses in the current streak have come by 10 points or fewer. Miami is seven games behind first-place Buffalo (8-1) in the AFC East.
What's next
The Dolphins visit the Buffalo Bills at Highmark Stadium on Sunday, Nov. 22, at 1 p.m., with McCord in line to keep starting while Willis is on injured reserve, as ESPN reported last week. Miami then hosts the Jets on Nov. 29 and visits Denver on Dec. 6. Willis is first eligible to return in Week 14, when the Dolphins host the Chicago Bears on Dec. 13.
The Colts turn around quickly, visiting Houston on Thursday night with Jones remaining the starter, coach Shane Steichen said.
Spotted an issue with this article?
Have something to say about this story?
Write us a letterComments
No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.
Related Coverage

Trevor Lawrence Throws for 352 Yards and 3 TDs as Jaguars Rout Titans 40-23 to Improve to 7-2
3h ago

Tarasov shuts out Lightning 2-0, ending Tampa Bay's franchise-record 8-0 home start
4h ago

Robertson's OT goal lifts Stars past Panthers 2-1 as Matthew Tkachuk reaches 700 career points
5h ago

Florida college football roundup: FAU and FIU fall on the road, FAMU edges Mississippi Valley State
9h ago