Back to Florida News

Orlando City's Season Ends as FC Cincinnati Rallies for 3-1 Wild-Card Win

The Florida Press Newsroom5 min read
Orlando City's Season Ends as FC Cincinnati Rallies for 3-1 Wild-Card Win
Photo: Tanner Pearson/Getty Images, via ESPN

Orlando City's 2026 season ended Thursday night at Inter&Co Stadium, where FC Cincinnati erased an early deficit and beat the Lions 3-1 in a rainy MLS Cup Playoffs Eastern Conference wild-card match. Evander scored in each half and set up Samuel Gidi's 85th-minute clincher, sending Cincinnati into a best-of-three Round One series against Supporters' Shield winner Nashville SC.

Martín Ojeda had given Orlando City a 1-0 lead in the 26th minute, but Evander converted a penalty kick just before halftime and scored again four minutes into the second half. The loss closed a turbulent year for the Lions, who changed coaches early in the season, added French star Antoine Griezmann in the summer and needed a Decision Day win just to reach the wild-card round.

Lineups

Perelman sent out a 4-4-2, according to ESPN's lineup data: Crépeau in goal; Griffin Dorsey, David Brekalo, Iago Teodoro and Vinícius Nogueira across the back; Eduard Atuesta and Luis Otávio in central midfield with Angulo and Marco Pašalić wide; and Ojeda paired with Griezmann up front. Justin Ellis, who had 11 regular-season assists according to MLSsoccer.com, started on the bench. Cincinnati countered with a 3-5-2 built around Evander, who led the club with 14 goals and 17 assists in the regular season, and Barlow in attack.

How the match turned

Orlando City, the No. 8 seed in the East, started brightly. In the 26th minute Iván Angulo slipped a through ball to Ojeda, who finished with his left foot from the left side of the box into the bottom right corner, according to ESPN's match log. It was Ojeda's second goal in nine career postseason matches, the AP noted.

Cincinnati, the No. 9 seed, leveled it in the 43rd minute. Pavel Bucha was fouled by Orlando City midfielder Marco Pašalić in the box, and Evander sent the penalty into the bottom left corner. Cincinnati made two halftime substitutions, sending on Alvas Powell and José Martínez, and took the lead in the 49th minute when Evander finished a pass from Tom Barlow from the center of the box.

Orlando City pushed for an equalizer, bringing on Ellis and Adrián Marín in the 53rd minute and Joran Gerbet in the 55th and adding forward Daryl Dike in the 75th. Instead, Evander turned provider in the 85th minute, setting up Gidi for a right-footed shot into the top right corner. It was Gidi's first goal in his fifth postseason appearance.

The goals, from ESPN's match data:

MinuteTeamScorerAssistScore
26'Orlando CityMartín OjedaIván Angulo1-0 Orlando
43'CincinnatiEvander (penalty)None1-1
49'CincinnatiEvanderTom Barlow2-1 Cincinnati
85'CincinnatiSamuel GidiEvander3-1 Cincinnati

The statistics showed how much of the ball Orlando City had without making it count. The Lions held 57.8% of possession and outshot Cincinnati 27-10, but both teams put eight shots on target, according to ESPN. Cincinnati goalkeeper Roman Celentano made six saves, while Orlando City's Maxime Crépeau made five. Cincinnati was shown four yellow cards to Orlando City's two.

Dike injured after coming on

Dike's night lasted only a few minutes at full strength. He was booked in the 77th minute and went down injured moments later, and because Orlando City had used all of its substitution windows, he stayed on the field for the rest of the match, ESPN reported.

Interim coach Martín Perelman said after the match that he had not yet spoken with the medical staff. "I think it's something with his hamstring, since that's where he was holding, so I assume he might have some kind of tear or something similar in the hamstring, but I'm not certain," Perelman said, according to ESPN. He defended the decision to bring Dike on, saying, "You never expect a player to come on with 15 minutes left and then get injured; that's not something you anticipate."

ESPN noted that Dike has a lengthy injury history, including a season-ending hamstring injury in 2022 and Achilles tendon ruptures in 2023 and 2024.

A season of change in Orlando

Orlando City finished the regular season 13-14-7 with 46 points, eighth in the Eastern Conference. The club dismissed coach Oscar Pareja after a start in which the team won only one of its first eight league matches, and Perelman took over on an interim basis, according to MLSsoccer.com.

The attack carried the team. Ojeda scored 16 regular-season goals, matching his career high from 2025, and was named winner of the 2026 MLS Goal of the Year, the club announced. Griezmann, who joined from Atlético Madrid in July, had 14 goals and eight assists in 18 games and was named 2026 MLS Newcomer of the Year. He started up front alongside Ojeda on Thursday.

The defense was another matter. ESPN's season review noted that Orlando City allowed 78 goals in the regular season, the second-worst defensive record in the league this year and the second-worst in MLS history. The Lions also reached the semifinals of the U.S. Open Cup.

Orlando City qualified by beating the New England Revolution 1-0 on Decision Day, while Cincinnati dropped into the wild-card spot with a 2-0 loss at Nashville the same day. Both teams finished with 46 points; Cincinnati went 12-12-10.

Perelman summed up the mood afterward. "We are very disappointed because we wanted to bring happiness to our fans, to our families, and everyone here at the stadium, and we couldn't," he said, according to ESPN, adding that the effort was there even if it was not enough.

Series history and what's next for Cincinnati

Thursday's match was the first postseason meeting between the clubs, which had gone 5-5-5 in 15 regular-season games, according to MLSsoccer.com. This season Cincinnati beat Orlando City 6-2 at home at the end of May, and the teams drew 1-1 in Orlando on Aug. 15, the AP reported.

Cincinnati opens its Round One series at Nashville on Sunday at 4 p.m. Eastern on Apple TV.

Florida's playoff hopes shift to Inter Miami

With Orlando City out, Inter Miami CF is Florida's remaining team in the MLS Cup Playoffs. Inter Miami opens its best-of-three Round One series against the Columbus Crew on Saturday, Nov. 21, at 6 p.m. Eastern at Nu Stadium in Miami, according to ESPN's schedule.

Spotted an issue with this article?

Have something to say about this story?

Write us a letter

Comments

Commenting is temporarily unavailable.

No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.

Related Coverage