Back to Florida News

Rays Face Tuesday Rule 5 Deadline With One Open 40-Man Spot as Erik Neander Doubles Down on Development and Keeping Drew Rasmussen

The Florida Press Newsroom5 min read
Rays Face Tuesday Rule 5 Deadline With One Open 40-Man Spot as Erik Neander Doubles Down on Development and Keeping Drew Rasmussen
Photo: MLB.com

The Tampa Bay Rays face a 6 p.m. ET deadline Tuesday to add Rule 5-eligible prospects to their 40-man roster or risk losing them in December's Rule 5 Draft, the first roster test of an offseason in which baseball operations president Erik Neander has said the AL champions will lean on internal development rather than outside spending. As of Tuesday morning, Major League Baseball's transaction log showed no Rays additions yet.

Tampa Bay entered the day with 39 players on its 40-man roster and five of its Top 30 prospects eligible for the draft, according to MLB.com. That leaves one open spot, so protecting more than one player will require removing someone else.

Who is eligible

Players who signed at 18 or younger become Rule 5-eligible after five seasons, and those who signed at 19 or older after four, unless they are on a 40-man roster. A team that drafts a player in the Major League phase must keep him on its big-league roster all season or offer him back. MLB Pipeline lists five Rays Top 30 prospects in that position this year:

ProspectPositionRays Top 30 rank
Santiago SuarezRHPNo. 16
Xavier Isaac1BNo. 18
Jackson BaumeisterRHPNo. 24
TJ NicholsRHPNo. 27
Tre' Morgan1BNo. 29

MLB.com's prospect writers called Isaac the better bet of the two first basemen to be protected, citing power potential at the top of the scouting scale. Isaac hit .255/.400/.510 with 24 home runs in 425 plate appearances at Double-A Montgomery before a late-August promotion, then batted .271 with a .413 on-base percentage at Triple-A Durham, according to DRaysBay, though he struck out in roughly 28 to 31 percent of his plate appearances at both levels.

Morgan, a former LSU standout known for his glove, had a down year. He hit .241/.303/.405 with nine homers in 243 plate appearances at Durham, posting career-worst contact and strikeout rates and spending nearly three months on the injured list, according to MLB.com and DRaysBay. Both players have appeared on Top 100 lists in the past.

On the pitching side, Suarez threw 126 innings at Double-A with a 4.50 ERA before a late promotion to Triple-A. Baumeister posted a 5.14 ERA and a 25.7 percent strikeout rate in 103 1/3 innings at Double-A, with command his main obstacle, according to DRaysBay, which noted that FanGraphs grades all five of his pitches as average or better.

DRaysBay also flagged several players outside the Top 30 whom other clubs might target, including Durham catcher Tatem Levins, who led the Bulls with a 95 wRC+ and 13 homers and was passed over in last year's draft; outfielder Homer Bush Jr., who stole 38 bases; right-hander Junior William; and left-handed reliever Yereny Teus, who struck out 38.1 percent of the hitters he faced at Single-A.

Who could lose a roster spot

Making room is the harder part. DRaysBay lists pitchers Alexander Alberto, Joe Boyle, Garrett Cleavinger, Alex Cook, Jesse Scholtens and Edwin Uceta, plus position players Jadher Areinamo, Carson Williams and Nick Fortes, as being on the roster bubble. Cleavinger, projected to earn $3.7 million in his final arbitration year, and Fortes, projected at $3.4 million, also face Friday's non-tender deadline. Cleavinger went from one of the Rays' most reliable relievers in 2025 to one of their least dependable in 2026.

The Rays have already reshaped the roster. On Nov. 2 they reinstated injured players including Ryan Pepiot, Jacob Melton and Uceta, selected the contracts of Alberto and outfielder Jack Suwinski from Durham, traded right-hander Evan Reifert to Houston for cash and outrighted Jonathan Heasley, according to MLB's transaction log. Nick Madrigal elected free agency, and the club declined mutual options on starter Nick Martinez and center fielder Cedric Mullins. Freddy Peralta, Gavin Lux and Jorge Mateo also became free agents.

Neander: 'double down' on development

Neander, named MLB Executive of the Year last week for the second time, laid out the approach at the general managers meetings in Las Vegas last week. "We went from 77 wins to 98, improved by 21 games, largely through a lot of internal development," he told MLB.com's Mark Feinsand. "We need to double down on that development."

The Rays led the American League for most of the regular season, won the pennant and reached the World Series for the third time in franchise history before losing to Milwaukee in five games. Most of the roster returns, including every hitter who played a meaningful role in the postseason, according to MLB.com, along with deadline addition Liam Hicks, speedster Chandler Simpson and Victor Mesa Jr.

Neander said the priority this winter is usually a particular player profile rather than a big outside name, and MLB.com noted that a young, controllable group of position players could free money for pitching.

Keeping Drew Rasmussen

The biggest question is whether Tampa Bay keeps its ace. The Rays exercised Drew Rasmussen's 2027 club option on Oct. 31 rather than pay a $500,000 buyout. The option rose from $8 million to $20 million after he stayed healthy and made at least 28 starts, according to the Associated Press. Rasmussen went 16-5 with a 2.67 ERA in 30 starts and a career-high 172 innings, then went 2-1 with a 2.20 ERA in five postseason starts, including a no-hit bid into the eighth inning in a 1-0 Division Series win over the Yankees.

A $20 million salary is high by Rays standards, and he can become a free agent after 2027, which has made him a popular trade candidate in offseason speculation. Neander signaled the club intends to keep him. "Not quite sure how that's possible next year without someone like Drew," he said of the goal of winning more in October, adding that the Rays would do everything they can for Rasmussen to anchor the 2027 rotation. MLB.com did not report any extension talks.

The projected rotation includes Rasmussen, Shane McClanahan, Griffin Jax, Ian Seymour and a healthy Pepiot, with closer Bryan Baker, Tyler Wells and Cam Booser at the back of the bullpen, according to MLB.com.

What's next

The Rays' 40-man decisions are due by 6 p.m. Tuesday. The non-tender deadline for arbitration-eligible players follows Friday, Nov. 20. The current collective bargaining agreement expires Dec. 1, and the Major League phase of the Rule 5 Draft is scheduled for Dec. 9 at the Winter Meetings in San Diego, a timeline MLB.com noted could be affected if no new labor deal is in place.

Spotted an issue with this article?

Have something to say about this story?

Write us a letter

Comments

Commenting is temporarily unavailable.

No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.

Related Coverage