Sam O'Reilly Scores His First NHL Goal and Jake Guentzel Adds Two as Lightning Beat Capitals 5-2

Sam O'Reilly needed 2 minutes and 11 seconds to give the Tampa Bay Lightning the start they wanted on Tuesday night. The 20-year-old rookie scored his first NHL goal, Jake Guentzel added two more and the Lightning beat the Washington Capitals 5-2 at Benchmark International Arena in Tampa.
John Carlson, who spent 17 seasons in Washington, had three assists against his former team. Andrei Vasilevskiy made 25 saves for his 10th win of the season, according to NHL.com, and Anthony Cirelli sealed it with an empty-net goal. The win lifted Tampa Bay to 14-5-2 overall and 9-1-0 at home, three days after its first home loss of the season.
O'Reilly breaks through
O'Reilly was called up from the American Hockey League's Syracuse Crunch on Nov. 10, and Tuesday was his fourth NHL game. His goal came off a play that started in the neutral zone: Brayden Point fed Jeff Viel, changed off the ice for O'Reilly, and Viel found the rookie in the slot. O'Reilly snapped a shot past Capitals goalie Logan Thompson. Viel and Point were credited with the assists.
The goal gave O'Reilly two points, a goal and an assist, through four games. He told reporters the goal was special and that scoring it at home was a feeling he would not forget, according to NHL.com. Coach Jon Cooper said it was cool that the rookie's first goal came in a game against Alex Ovechkin.
Three goals in the first period
Tampa Bay kept pushing. At 10:36 of the first, Charle-Edouard D'Astous beat Thompson from the high slot, with Carlson and Ryan McDonagh assisting. The Lightning's website noted that all three points on the goal went to defensemen, and that it repeated an odd pattern from the opening goal: McDonagh, like Point before him, picked up the second assist after changing off the ice for the eventual scorer.
At 13:11, Guentzel made it 3-0, finishing a rebound at the top of the crease after a Nikita Kucherov one-timer from the right wall. It stood as the game-winning goal. Washington answered at 16:12, moments after Zemgus Girgensons was hurt, when Alex Tuch scored from the slot after the Capitals forced a turnover in the Lightning end. The goal, assisted by Aliaksei Protas, was Tuch's team-leading 12th of the season.
Guentzel restored the three-goal lead at 11:34 of the second period, redirecting a Carlson shot-pass from the low slot over Thompson's glove for his 13th goal of the season. Ryan Leonard pulled Washington within 4-2 at 4:53 of the third with a shot from the top of the circles, but Cirelli knocked the puck off Leonard's stick at the Lightning blue line and slid it into the empty net at 17:19.
Vasilevskiy holds the line
The score flattered Tampa Bay at times. The Capitals created several high-quality chances, especially in the first period, and outshot the Lightning 12-4 in the third while holding a 25-13 edge in shot attempts in that period, according to the team's game notes. After Leonard's goal cut the lead to two early in the period, the Lightning did not score again until Cirelli's empty-netter. Vasilevskiy stopped 25 of 27 shots, a .926 save percentage, per NHL.com. (The Lightning's postgame notes credited him with 26 saves.) Thompson made 20 saves on 25 shots for Washington.
Cooper said the early goals took the sting out of the shutout loss to Detroit and credited Vasilevskiy with keeping his team in front during its lapses, according to NHL.com. Carlson said an early lead at home sets the tone. Tampa Bay is now 11-0-1 when scoring first, the best mark in the league in that situation.
The game's three stars, as listed by the Lightning, were Guentzel, Vasilevskiy and Carlson.
Milestones for Kucherov and Carlson
Kucherov had two assists in his 900th NHL game, becoming the fifth player in franchise history to reach that mark. He has 1,154 points, 409 goals and 745 assists, in his first 900 games, the fourth most by a player born outside North America over that span, according to NHL.com.
Carlson's three-assist night came against the team he played for across 17 seasons. Washington traded him to Anaheim on March 5, and he signed with Tampa Bay on July 1.
The night also carried weight for Ovechkin, who played his final regular-season game in Tampa. The NHL's career goals leader, with 930, announced on Oct. 5 that this will be his last season. He has one goal in 19 games this season and none in his last 14, matching his longest drought, set in November 2023.
Injuries: Girgensons leaves
The win came with a cost. Girgensons, a forward, left late in the first period after taking a hit from Capitals defenseman Matt Roy and did not return. Cooper did not have an update after the game. Cirelli moved into Girgensons' spot on the matchup line with Pontus Holmberg and Ilya Mikheyev.
The Lightning were already shorthanded. Conor Geekie was placed on injured reserve with an upper-body injury, and Brandon Hagel missed the game with a lower-body injury, according to NHL.com.
Context: a bounce back at home
Tampa Bay entered Tuesday coming off a 2-0 loss to the Detroit Red Wings on Saturday, a shutout that ended the Lightning's franchise-record 8-0 start at home. The response was immediate: three goals in the first 13:11.
Washington, meanwhile, dropped to 10-9-0 with its third straight loss, its first three-game skid of the season. The Capitals have allowed 17 goals over the three losses and 33 while losing five of their last seven. Tuch said his team was not tight enough in its own zone, and coach Spencer Carbery said the Capitals kept fighting after falling behind 3-0 but did not play well enough, according to NHL.com.
What's next
The Lightning stay home to face the league-leading Edmonton Oilers on Thursday at 7:30 p.m. Edmonton arrives 16-3-3 overall and 10-0-1 on the road, setting up a matchup between one of the NHL's best home teams and its best traveling team. The team's website lists Thursday's game as part of a six-game homestand.
Spotted an issue with this article?
Have something to say about this story?
Write us a letterComments
No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.
Related Coverage

Miami Holds at No. 7 and Florida Enters at No. 24 in the Third College Football Playoff Rankings
1h ago

Giannis Antetokounmpo Nearly Posts a Triple-Double Against His Former Team as Heat Beat Bucks 137-130 on Vice City Night
4h ago

Urban Klavzar Scores Career-High 24 as No. 1 Florida Beats Notre Dame 86-78 After Boogie Fland Exits With Shoulder Injury
23h ago

Manny Diaz and Glenn Schumann Emerge as Top Names in Florida State's Coaching Search, Report Says
1d ago