43 Florida Hospitals Earn Leapfrog Straight-A Safety Honors as State Slips to Ninth

Forty-three Florida hospitals earned The Leapfrog Group's "Straight A" recognition in the fall 2026 Hospital Safety Grades, the second-highest total of any state behind California's 63, according to a WUSF Health News Florida analysis of the results published Friday. The designation goes to hospitals that have earned an A in at least five consecutive grading periods, or every cycle over the past two and a half years.
The overall picture for Florida held steady. Eighty-one of the state's 191 participating hospitals received an A, about 42 percent, the same count as in the spring. But other states gained ground, and Florida slipped from seventh to ninth nationally in the share of hospitals earning the top grade. Two Florida hospitals, both in Ocala, received D grades, and eight more went ungraded because of a federal court fight over how Leapfrog scores hospitals that skip its voluntary survey.
What the grades measure
Leapfrog, a national nonprofit backed by employers and other health care purchasers, issues its Hospital Safety Grades twice a year, in the spring and fall. Each letter grade is built from 22 measures drawn from federal data and Leapfrog's own voluntary hospital survey. The measures focus on how well hospitals protect patients from preventable errors, injuries, accidents and infections, and they include routine practices such as hand hygiene before every patient interaction.
Leapfrog released the fall 2026 grades this week. Nationally, about 900 hospitals earned an A, 774 earned a B, 655 earned a C, 35 received a D and three received an F. Leapfrog counted 431 Straight A hospitals across the country, including 223 that have earned an A in all eight grading cycles since spring 2023. Eleven hospitals nationwide have earned an A in every cycle since Leapfrog began issuing the grades in 2012.
The group itself cautions that its grades should not be the only factor in choosing where to receive care. Consumers can look up any graded hospital by name at HospitalSafetyGrade.org.
Florida's Straight A hospitals by system
AdventHealth dominated the Florida list, accounting for 15 of the 43 Straight A hospitals, most of them in Central Florida and the Tampa Bay suburbs. The rest were spread across Baptist, HCA Florida, Orlando Health, the St. Joseph's, Morton Plant and Mease hospitals in the Tampa Bay area, Sarasota Memorial and a group of other hospitals, based on the WUSF list. The table below groups them by the name each hospital carries.
| System or group | Straight A hospitals | Locations |
|---|---|---|
| AdventHealth | 15 | Apopka, Carrollwood, Celebration, Dade City, DeLand, East Orlando, Fish Memorial, Kissimmee, New Smyrna Beach, Ocala, Orlando, Wesley Chapel, Winter Garden, Winter Park, Zephyrhills |
| St. Joseph's | 3 | Tampa, Lutz, Riverview |
| Baptist | 3 | South Miami, West Kendall, Jacksonville Beach |
| HCA Florida | 3 | Kendall, Gainesville (North Florida Hospital), South Tampa |
| Orlando Health | 3 | Horizon West, Melbourne, South Lake (Clermont) |
| Morton Plant | 2 | Clearwater, New Port Richey (North Bay) |
| Mease | 2 | Countryside (Safety Harbor), Dunedin |
| Sarasota Memorial | 2 | Sarasota, North Venice |
| Other hospitals | 10 | Cape Coral, HealthPark (Fort Myers), Lee Memorial (Fort Myers), Jupiter Medical Center, Lakewood Ranch, Mayo Clinic Jacksonville, Memorial Hospital Miramar, Oviedo Medical Center, St. Anthony's (St. Petersburg), Winter Haven |
The geographic spread is notable. Central Florida, from Volusia County through Orange, Osceola and Lake counties, accounts for the largest cluster, driven by AdventHealth and Orlando Health. The Tampa Bay area, including Pinellas, Pasco and Hillsborough counties, contributes another large group through AdventHealth, the St. Joseph's, Morton Plant and Mease hospitals, St. Anthony's and HCA Florida South Tampa. Southwest Florida is represented by Sarasota Memorial's two campuses, Lakewood Ranch Medical Center and three Lee County hospitals. South Florida has Baptist's two Miami-Dade hospitals, HCA Florida Kendall, Memorial Hospital Miramar and Jupiter Medical Center, while Northeast Florida has Mayo Clinic in Jacksonville and Baptist Medical Center Beaches. No Panhandle hospital appears on the Straight A list.
David Verinder, president and CEO of Sarasota Memorial Health System, told WUSF that earning an A is an achievement, "but sustaining that level of performance year after year takes extraordinary teamwork, vigilance and a shared commitment to doing what is best for every patient, every day."
Where Florida ranks
Florida's ninth-place finish is a step back from its spring showing but remains well above where the state stood a year ago. In fall 2025, Florida ranked 15th, with 37.9 percent of its hospitals earning an A. The spring 2026 grades lifted the state to seventh, at 42.2 percent. In the fall, Florida's share edged up slightly to 42.4 percent, but it lost two spots as other states improved faster.
| Grading period | Florida rank | Share of hospitals with an A |
|---|---|---|
| Fall 2025 | 15th | 37.9% |
| Spring 2026 | 7th | 42.2% |
| Fall 2026 | 9th | 42.4% |
Connecticut led the nation in the fall, with 64.3 percent of its hospitals earning an A. Utah, at 55.2 percent, New Jersey, at 53.7 percent, South Carolina, at 52.9 percent, and Virginia, at 52.1 percent, rounded out the top five. Five states, Iowa, North Dakota, South Dakota, Vermont and Wyoming, had no A hospitals at all.
Florida finished well ahead of its neighbors. Louisiana ranked 10th, at 38.6 percent, while Georgia placed 27th, at 25.6 percent, and Alabama ranked 45th, at 13.0 percent.
The lower grades: two D's in Ocala
At the other end of the scale, two Florida hospitals received D grades in the fall: HCA Florida Ocala Hospital and HCA Florida West Marion Hospital, both in Marion County, according to WUSF. Florida had 37 hospitals with C grades. WUSF did not report any Florida hospital receiving an F; nationally, only three hospitals got the failing grade.
The two Ocala D grades mark a reversal for hospitals that HCA has previously promoted for earning A grades from Leapfrog. The grades are one of several quality ratings that hospitals publicize, and a single cycle's grade can move with changes in reported infection rates, survey answers or federal data.
Eight Florida hospitals left ungraded
Leapfrog did not assign grades to eight Florida hospitals in the fall report, a carryover from a lawsuit filed by five South Florida hospitals owned by Tenet and operated as the Palm Beach Health Network: Good Samaritan Medical Center and St. Mary's Medical Center in West Palm Beach, Delray Medical Center, Palm Beach Gardens Medical Center and West Boca Medical Center.
In March 2026, U.S. District Judge Donald Middlebrooks in the Southern District of Florida sided with the hospitals. He found that Leapfrog's practice of converting missing survey data into the lowest possible scores unfairly penalized hospitals that chose not to take part in its voluntary survey, and he ordered Leapfrog to remove the hospitals' grades and tell users that some past ratings relied on a methodology he called "deceptive and unfair." In June, WUSF reported that a federal judge denied Leapfrog's appeal of that decision, and Middlebrooks rejected the hospitals' request to make Leapfrog cover $10.5 million in legal fees for now, saying it could be refiled once appeals are exhausted. WUSF reported Friday that Leapfrog is still appealing.
Leapfrog responded by withholding grades nationwide from hospitals that did not participate in its survey, rather than only the five plaintiffs. In the spring, Florida's ungraded group included the five Palm Beach Health Network hospitals, Baptist Hospital in Pensacola and Gulf Breeze Hospital, and DeSoto Memorial Hospital in Arcadia. Nationally, Leapfrog's fall methodology report listed about 450 hospitals as "Grade Not Assigned."
What it means for patients
For Floridians choosing where to have elective surgery or a planned procedure, the grades offer one view of how consistently a hospital avoids preventable harm, such as infections picked up during a stay, falls and surgical errors. The Straight A list is weighted toward large systems in metro areas, so patients in rural counties and much of North Florida have fewer nearby hospitals with long A streaks.
The ungraded hospitals present a separate wrinkle. A missing grade does not mean a hospital is unsafe, only that it did not take part in Leapfrog's survey, and patients looking up those facilities will find no letter at all.
What's next
Leapfrog's next round of grades is due in spring 2027, when Florida hospitals will try to extend their streaks and the two Ocala hospitals will have a chance to move off a D. The appeal in the Palm Beach Health Network case will determine whether Leapfrog can return to grading non-participating hospitals under its old approach, or whether the current practice of leaving them ungraded becomes permanent.
Spotted an issue with this article?
Have something to say about this story?
Write us a letterComments
No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.
Related Coverage

Flu Cases Jump in Florida as First Cold Front Arrives, With State Among Three Worst on National Flu Index
4d ago

US Loses Measles Elimination Status After 26 Years as Florida Logs 163 Cases and Fights Over School Vaccines
5d ago

Florida Health Agency Puts $1 Placeholder in Budget Request for Autism Therapy Task Force Recommendations
Nov 12

On Veterans Day, Florida's Veterans Agency Asks Lawmakers for Millions More to Staff and Repair State Nursing Homes
Nov 11