Baker County Jury Acquits 2 Men in Macclenny Stand Your Ground Shooting Case

A Baker County jury on Monday, Nov. 16, found Jamarian Byrd and Travis Roberts Jr. not guilty on every count in the June 2025 shooting in Macclenny that killed 19-year-old Devin Powers Jr. and wounded a 14-year-old, ending a prosecution that had turned into a closely watched test of how Florida applies its Stand Your Ground law.
The two men had been indicted on first-degree premeditated murder and faced life in prison if convicted. Five months before trial, a circuit judge refused to grant them immunity under Stand Your Ground, ruling that although they were justified in firing when Powers shot at them, that justification ended once he turned to retreat. The Jacksonville NAACP publicly questioned that decision. On Monday, jurors sided with the defense on all charges, WJXT News4JAX reported.
The verdict
Byrd and Roberts were acquitted of these charges, according to News4JAX:
- First-degree premeditated murder
- Aggravated battery
- Three counts of shooting into an occupied dwelling
- One count of discharging a firearm in public
Byrd was 22 and Roberts was 24 when Action News Jax reported on the case in December 2025. Both men had been held in the Baker County Detention Center without bail since their arrests, according to Slate.
Kalissa Warnick, Roberts' mother, told News4JAX after the verdict that the wait had been nerve-wracking and that she would finally be able to hold her son after 17 months. She said she planned to "drown him with love" and praised the defense: "They fought a good fight and they got the job done." Latelsa Bowen, Byrd's mother, described the past year to the station as "hurt, scared, anxious, just everything."
The Eighth Judicial Circuit State Attorney's Office, which prosecutes felonies in Baker County, had not issued a public statement on the verdict in the coverage reviewed by The Florida Press, and no reaction from Powers' family had been reported as of Tuesday.
What happened on June 26, 2025
The shooting happened on the evening of June 26, 2025, near Quail Lane and South Boulevard in Macclenny, the Baker County seat about 30 miles west of Jacksonville. Investigators said it followed a robbery in which a teenager was assaulted and a handgun was taken from him, News4JAX reported. A 22-year-old man was arrested in connection with that robbery but was not charged in the shooting.
During the confrontation that followed, Powers raised and fired a shotgun at Byrd and Roberts, according to the judge's later findings as reported by News4JAX. The two men returned fire. Powers was hit and died on July 2, 2025. A 14-year-old was also wounded and was treated and released from the hospital; The Florida Press is not naming the teen.
Baker County Sheriff Scotty Rhoden initially described the shooting as self-defense, according to Slate, which quoted him saying that at that point the men's lives were in fear. Eleven days after the shooting, Slate reported, Byrd and Roberts were charged with first-degree murder and related offenses, and a Baker County grand jury later returned the indictment.
Powers' mother, Ashely Goodin, told Action News Jax in December 2025 that her son was her only child and that he left behind a five-year-old son. She said he had been preparing to start a new job and graduate, and that she believed more people were involved than those who had been arrested.
The Stand Your Ground ruling
Before trial, Byrd and Roberts asked the court to dismiss the case under Florida's Stand Your Ground law, which grants immunity from prosecution to people who lawfully use force in self-defense. Since a 2017 change to the statute, once a defendant raises a prima facie claim of self-defense at a pretrial hearing, prosecutors must overcome it by clear and convincing evidence.
Circuit Judge Denise Ferrero found that the defense had cleared that first hurdle, writing that Roberts had established a prima facie claim of self-defense, according to News4JAX's review of the order. In the June 17, 2026, ruling, Slate reported, she nonetheless denied immunity. The order said the men were entitled to use deadly force when Powers raised and pointed a shotgun at them, but that the entitlement "dissolved the moment" Powers began to retreat and was no longer a deadly threat.
The judge's order said the men kept firing as Powers ran back toward a home, that they did not know him and had no prior conflict with him, that they outnumbered him, and that they "sprayed the neighborhood with at least 47 bullets," according to News4JAX.
The defense challenged the ruling. In a July 1 petition, Byrd's attorney argued that Powers was still armed and the danger had not ended when the men kept shooting, and asked for an emergency pause while an appeals court considered the matter, News4JAX reported. The case ultimately proceeded to trial in November. A pretrial denial of immunity does not prevent a defendant from arguing self-defense to a jury, which is what the two men did.
The NAACP and the wider debate
The Jacksonville Branch NAACP said in a July 1 news release that it was deeply concerned by the denial of immunity and called for fair and equal application of Florida's Stand Your Ground law. The release said justice must be served fairly, consistently and without regard to race, neighborhood or background. Branch President Isaiah Rumlin told News4JAX at the time, "We feel that this is a clear stand your ground case," and urged community leaders to speak out.
The case drew national attention as well. Slate, in an August essay, framed the prosecution around race: Byrd and Roberts are Black, and Powers was white, the outlet reported. Warnick told News4JAX in July that a conviction would have meant life in prison, calling the prospect heartbreaking.
What's next
The acquittal is final. Under the constitutional ban on double jeopardy, the state cannot appeal a not-guilty verdict or retry Byrd and Roberts on the same charges. The verdict does not resolve every question Powers' family has raised: his mother said in December that she wanted everyone responsible held accountable, and the separate robbery case that preceded the shooting has not been reported as resolved. The Baker County Sheriff's Office has not said whether any further charges are under consideration.
Spotted an issue with this article?
Have something to say about this story?
Write us a letterComments
No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.
Related Coverage

Osceola deputy fatally shoots woman the sheriff says pointed a gun at a man outside an Old Town Kissimmee bar
17h ago

Florida set for record 20th execution of 2026 as Thomas Overton faces lethal injection Thursday for Keys double murder
20h ago

Accused gunman Henry Tenon due in court in Jared Bridegan murder case days after former landlord gets life sentence
1d ago

Lake City Daycare Worker Sentenced to 20 Years in Prison After Infant Suffered Skull Fracture and Brain Bleeding
1d ago