Back to Florida News

Doral Councilwoman Maureen Porras Keeps Pushing to Revisit City's ICE 287(g) Pact After City Attorney Blocks the Item

The Florida Press Newsroom5 min read
Doral Councilwoman Maureen Porras Keeps Pushing to Revisit City's ICE 287(g) Pact After City Attorney Blocks the Item
Photo via WLRN

Doral Councilwoman Maureen Porras says she will keep pushing for a public discussion of the city's 287(g) immigration enforcement agreement with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, after City Attorney Lorenzo Cobiella kept her proposed agenda item off the council's calendar with a warning that even debating the pact could expose council members to removal by the state.

The standoff in Doral, a city of about 81,000 people that is home to the nation's largest Venezuelan American community, has become one of South Florida's sharpest local fights over immigration enforcement, as residents and business owners say federal arrests have emptied restaurants and kept workers home.

What Porras asked for

Porras, a Republican and an immigration lawyer for more than 12 years who won reelection this month by 12 votes, asked to place a discussion item on the council agenda to reevaluate the 287(g) agreement. In an interview with Jim DeFede on CBS News Miami's "Facing South Florida," aired Sunday, she said she was not seeking any binding action. "There was no actual action that I was requiring or requesting," she said, according to WLRN.

She said she wanted to talk the agreement through with her colleagues, the city attorney and residents in public, noting that Florida's Sunshine Law bars council members from discussing city business with one another outside a noticed meeting. "We have to evaluate it at the level of a community," she said. She wants the item on the November or December agenda.

Porras told the Miami New Times last week that Cobiella was "blocking my ability as a Council member to bring forward legislation without any justification," and said she was looking at legal options.

The city attorney's reasons

In a memo to council members, Cobiella wrote that discussing the agreement "could be viewed as an anticipatory breach of the agreement and an intent to violate state law," according to WLRN. He said Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier could step in to remove council members for holding the debate, and cited concerns about angering ICE.

Emails obtained by the Miami New Times laid out further objections:

  • Notice: a city ordinance requires items with a fiscal impact to be submitted two weeks before a meeting. Porras says the city charter requires only seven days for her kind of item.
  • Legal analysis: Cobiella said the legal and financial risks could not be analyzed in the time given, without saying when that analysis would be done.
  • Other cities: Uthmeier has said officials in Key West, Fort Myers, Orlando and Tampa violated state law by withdrawing from immigration agreements. Porras pointed to South Miami's legal challenge to the attorney general's position; Cobiella answered that South Miami never signed a 287(g) agreement, so its situation is different.
  • No implementation: Cobiella wrote that Doral "has not taken any steps to implement the agreement," including training officers or taking enforcement actions.

Cobiella did not respond to the New Times' request for further comment.

How Doral got here

The Doral City Council approved a resolution authorizing the 287(g) partnership in April 2025. At the time, Cobiella advised that not entering an agreement would put the city in violation of Florida law, citing the state's ban on so-called sanctuary cities and an opinion Uthmeier had issued to the city of Fort Myers, WLRN reported.

Porras voted for the agreement. She has said the council was told it was required under newly enacted state law, and that she supported it on the condition that Doral police would not actively enforce federal immigration law. She confirmed that no Doral officers have been trained with ICE under the program.

Whether the law actually requires a city like Doral to sign is disputed. Jeanette Ynfante, a senior staff attorney at the Southern Poverty Law Center, said in October that state statutes require only sheriffs and county jail operators to enter written agreements with ICE, while other local agencies must use their best efforts to support enforcement. "The city of Doral is not required to enter into a 287(g) agreement with ICE under Florida law," she told CBS News Miami.

The mayor's position

Mayor Christi Fraga, a Republican, has said the city's hands are tied. In October she said she entered the agreement based on the city legal team's advice and that the attorney's position has not changed. She has argued that the fear in the community comes from federal raids, not from local officers, and that Doral cannot stop federal agents from making arrests. She told CBS News Miami that city data shows Doral police have not taken part in ICE operations, and said she had contacted the attorney general's office, which indicated that withdrawing could conflict with state law.

In an email to the New Times, Fraga called the federal government's revocation of Temporary Protected Status for Venezuelans "difficult and heartbreaking," while maintaining that the city cannot exit the 287(g) agreement.

Pressure from residents and businesses

Pressure on City Hall has built for months. In September, South Florida Democratic leaders, including former U.S. Rep. Joe Garcia and South Miami Mayor Javier Fernández, rallied outside City Hall calling for the agreement to be rescinded, NBC 6 reported. In October, residents and business owners brought petitions to a council meeting. Eleazar Guevara, owner of La Sabrosita Parrilla & Grill, told CBS News Miami his business had fallen about 80% and that he was about to lose it.

Porras has said the federal crackdown has swept up law-abiding residents, including teachers who lost legal protections when TPS for Venezuelans ended, and that detainees are often transferred far from South Florida, making it hard for their lawyers to find them. She also argued that legal precedents have changed since Doral signed and that other municipalities are reconsidering their own agreements.

The political backdrop has shifted too. President Donald Trump carried Doral by 22 points two years ago, but the city voted overwhelmingly for Democrats this year, the New Times reported. Nationally, the Department of Homeland Security has said ICE set records in the fiscal year that ended Sept. 30, with more than 491,000 immigration arrests and more than 483,000 deportations, according to WLRN.

What's next

Porras says she will keep trying to get the item on a council agenda before the end of the year and is weighing legal options to challenge the city attorney's decision. The outcome of South Miami's challenge to the attorney general's position on immigration agreements could also shape whether Doral and other Florida cities feel free to revisit their pacts. For now, the agreement remains in place, and no council discussion has been scheduled.

Spotted an issue with this article?

Have something to say about this story?

Write us a letter

Comments

Commenting is temporarily unavailable.

No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.

Related Coverage