DeSantis withdraws death warrant for 74-year-old Thompson, leaving Robertson as Florida's lone Oct. 13 execution

Gov. Ron DeSantis has called off the execution of William Lee Thompson, a 74-year-old Florida death row prisoner whose lawyers say he has advanced dementia, withdrawing a death warrant for the first time since he took office. The decision, delivered in a Thursday afternoon letter to Florida State Prison Warden Randall Polk, came days before Thompson was set to die by lethal injection on Tuesday, Oct. 13, and hours after the Florida Supreme Court denied his request for a stay, according to CBS News Miami and The Associated Press.
The governor's letter gave no reason for the reversal. Thompson remains on death row, and a new warrant could be signed for him later, the AP reported. The second execution set for Tuesday, that of James Robertson for the 2008 killing of his cellmate at a Charlotte County prison, remains on the schedule.
The withdrawal turns what was planned as Florida's second double execution day of 2026 into a single execution, but it does little to slow a year in which the state has already put 16 people to death and is on pace to match or surpass the modern record it set in 2025.
A first for DeSantis
DeSantis has signed death warrants at a pace no Florida governor has matched since executions resumed in the late 1970s. The state carried out 19 executions in 2025, the most in a single year since the U.S. Supreme Court allowed capital punishment to resume in 1976. Until this week, every warrant he signed either ended in an execution or remained pending.
The Thompson case had drawn unusual attention because of the prisoner's age and health. His attorneys said he suffers from dementia along with serious physical illnesses, and more than 100 medical professionals signed a letter urging the governor to withdraw the warrant, according to earlier reporting from the Florida Phoenix and WLRN. Thompson's attorney, Bri Lacy, told the AP that his health is failing and that she hopes the Florida Department of Corrections will move him to an appropriate medical facility.
The competency fight
Under Florida law and U.S. Supreme Court precedent, the state cannot execute a prisoner who lacks the mental capacity to understand the death penalty and why it is being imposed. Thompson's legal team argued he had crossed that line.
According to filings described by CBS News Miami, a neuropsychologist met with Thompson on Sept. 15 and concluded he met the legal criteria for insanity because of dementia and significant cognitive decline. The Florida Tribune reported that the neuropsychologist found Thompson did not recognize he had been sentenced to death.
DeSantis responded by temporarily staying the execution and issuing Executive Order 26-192, which created a three-member psychiatric panel to examine Thompson. The order called for the panel to examine him on Oct. 1 and report the following day. The panel's findings have not been released, and the governor's office has not explained whether those findings drove the decision to withdraw the warrant.
Thompson's lawyers also sought a stay from the Florida Supreme Court, which denied the motion on Thursday. A few hours later, the governor's letter ended the execution plans.
The 1976 Miami-Dade case
Thompson was convicted in one of the oldest cases on Florida's death row. On March 30, 1976, in a Dade County motel room, Thompson and a co-defendant held two women and forced them to call relatives for money, according to the case summary cited by CBS News Miami. One of the women was beaten and tortured and died of internal bleeding. Thompson pleaded guilty to first-degree murder, kidnapping and sexual battery and was first sentenced to death in June 1976.
His case has passed through decades of appeals and resentencing. He was in his 20s when the crime occurred and has spent roughly five decades in prison.
Robertson execution still set for Tuesday
James Robertson, 63, is scheduled to die by lethal injection at noon Tuesday at Florida State Prison near Raiford, according to the warrant schedule reported by Fox 13 and death penalty trackers. Thompson's execution had been set for six hours later.
Robertson pleaded guilty to first-degree murder in Charlotte County for strangling his cellmate, Frank Hart, at Charlotte Correctional Institution north of Fort Myers in December 2008. He told investigators he killed Hart so he would be moved to death row, according to the AP. The Florida Supreme Court affirmed his conviction and death sentence in 2016, and Robertson later waived his remaining postconviction appeals and discharged his lawyers.
The Florida Supreme Court set an expedited briefing schedule in his warrant case. If the execution proceeds, Robertson would be the 17th person executed in Florida this year.
Florida's 2026 execution calendar
With Thompson's warrant withdrawn, three executions remain scheduled in Florida through early November, according to the governor's warrants and reporting by News4JAX, Fox 13 and CBS12.
| Date | Prisoner | Case | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Oct. 13 | James Robertson, 63 | 2008 killing of cellmate, Charlotte County | Scheduled, noon |
| Oct. 13 | William Lee Thompson, 74 | 1976 murder, Miami-Dade | Warrant withdrawn |
| Oct. 20 | William Reaves, 77 | 1986 killing of Indian River County deputy | Scheduled |
| Nov. 5 | Jesse Guardado, 64 | 2004 killing of Walton County woman | Scheduled |
Reaves was convicted of fatally shooting Indian River County Sheriff's Deputy Richard Raczkoski outside a Vero Beach convenience store in September 1986. DeSantis signed his warrant on Sept. 18. Reaves lost a bid to halt the execution in Indian River County circuit court and has appealed to the Florida Supreme Court, and his family has asked the governor for clemency, WPTV reported.
DeSantis signed Guardado's warrant on Oct. 5, which news outlets described as his 20th death warrant of the year. Guardado pleaded guilty to killing Jackie Malone, a 75-year-old Walton County woman who had helped him find housing and work after an earlier prison term, and was sentenced to death in 2005. The warrant states that clemency was considered and found not appropriate.
Record pace
Florida's 16th execution of 2026 took place Sept. 29, when Curtis Beasley was put to death at Florida State Prison for a 1995 killing. Beasley was the seventh prisoner over age 70 executed in Florida this year, according to CBS12. Earlier in September the state executed Harold Gene Lucas and Daniel Owen Conahan Jr.
When Guardado's warrant was signed, his scheduled execution was counted as the 20th of the year, one more than the 2025 record. With Thompson's execution called off, Guardado's would instead be the 19th if all three remaining executions proceed, tying last year's total. Any additional warrant signed for a date before Dec. 31 would push Florida past its record.
The state's pace has drawn national scrutiny. Florida leads the nation in executions this year, and in July it became the first state in nearly a decade to execute two prisoners on the same day, according to the AP. The botched execution attempt of Christa Pike in Tennessee last week has also prompted Florida defense attorneys to call for a review of lethal injection procedures, the Florida Phoenix reported.
What's next
Robertson's execution is set for noon Tuesday unless a court or the governor intervenes; Robertson has not pursued the extended appeals typical of warrant cases. Reaves is scheduled for Oct. 20 while his Florida Supreme Court appeal is pending, and Guardado is set for Nov. 5.
For Thompson, the immediate question is where he will be held and treated. His attorneys want him moved to a medical setting. The governor's office has not said whether it intends to sign a new warrant for him, and Thompson remains on death row.
Spotted an issue with this article?
Have something to say about this story?
Write us a letterComments
No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.
Related Coverage

Osceola deputy fatally shoots woman the sheriff says pointed a gun at a man outside an Old Town Kissimmee bar
8h ago

Florida set for record 20th execution of 2026 as Thomas Overton faces lethal injection Thursday for Keys double murder
11h ago

Accused gunman Henry Tenon due in court in Jared Bridegan murder case days after former landlord gets life sentence
15h ago

Lake City Daycare Worker Sentenced to 20 Years in Prison After Infant Suffered Skull Fracture and Brain Bleeding
1d ago