Back to Florida News

Former JEA CEO Vickie Cavey's Pension Calculated at $451,688 a Year, Pending Board Vote

The Florida Press Newsroom5 min read
Former JEA CEO Vickie Cavey's Pension Calculated at $451,688 a Year, Pending Board Vote
Photo via WJXT

Former JEA chief executive Vickie Cavey would collect an annual pension of $451,688.66 under a calculation by the City of Jacksonville Pension Office, nearly four times the $119,614.84 a year she was entitled to when she first retired from the city-owned utility in 2016. The figure is not final: the city's Pension Board of Trustees is scheduled to consider it on Dec. 17, and the amount is subject to federal limits that would cap what the pension plan itself can pay.

The calculation, first reported by News4JAX, comes less than two months after Cavey resigned as JEA's CEO amid a Jacksonville City Council investigation into workplace complaints and disputed fees at the city-owned electric, water and sewer utility.

How the pension office reached $451,688

Cavey is a member of the city's General Employees Pension Plan, and all of her credited service was with JEA, according to the pension office. The plan's formula multiplies a member's final monthly compensation by years of credited service and a 2.5% accrual rate for each year, with the accrual capped at 80% after 32 years of service.

Final monthly compensation is the average of a member's highest-paid 36 consecutive months, or 78 biweekly pay periods, within the final 10 years of employment. For Cavey, the office used salary data from April 8, 2016, through Oct. 9, 2026, a window that captures her time as CEO at the top of JEA's pay scale.

The office combined Cavey's service and pay from before her 2016 retirement with her later JEA employment. A break in service does not prevent that, the pension office said, as long as a retiree rejoins the plan for at least one year.

The office stressed that the calculation "is not final until the board ratifies it," and said an earlier amount provided by another city department was not the official determination. The city has said the increase is not tied to job performance and simply reflects how the formula works, Action News Jax reported.

The federal limit, and an open question for JEA

The calculated benefit is well above the $300,000 limit the IRS sets on annual payments from qualified pension plans for 2027, according to the pension office. At that limit, roughly $151,700 of Cavey's yearly benefit could not be paid from the plan. Action News Jax, using the 2026 cap of $290,000, put the gap at $161,688 a year.

Public employers can cover amounts above the federal cap through what is known as an excess benefit arrangement, paid outside the qualified plan. Participation is voluntary, and the pension office said the decision rests with JEA. The city and JEA have used general revenue to cover such amounts in the past, according to Action News Jax, but doing so is not required. JEA had not said publicly whether it would pay the difference.

From retiree to CEO

Cavey spent nearly four decades at JEA. She first left in 2016 after 32 years, with an annual pension just under $120,000, then returned to the utility and became its CEO in April 2024, first on an interim basis and later permanently. In February 2025, the JEA board approved a contract extension that raised her salary to $700,000 a year. Action News Jax reported that her CEO pay ranged from $500,000 to $721,000 a year.

Here is how the key figures line up:

DateEventFigure
2016Cavey retires after 32 years$119,614.84 annual pension
April 2024Becomes JEA CEOInterim, later permanent
February 2025Board approves contract extension$700,000 salary
Sept. 25, 2026Resignation takes effectFinal day as CEO
November 2026Pension office recalculates benefit$451,688.66 annual pension
Dec. 17, 2026Pension Board of Trustees meetsRatification pending
2027IRS limit on qualified plan payments$300,000

A turbulent final year

Cavey's last months at JEA were dominated by controversy. In February 2026, then-City Council President Kevin Carrico accused her of racism and of fostering a toxic work culture. Carrico created a special council investigative committee, initially chaired by Council Member Ron Salem, which examined the workplace allegations along with millions of dollars in capacity fees that JEA had failed to collect.

JEA hired an outside Tampa employment attorney to review the workplace complaints. That review, which included interviews with 65 employees who work closely with Cavey, did not substantiate claims that she created a toxic workplace, retaliated against employees or treated workers differently because of race, News4JAX reported. Company-wide employee surveys produced mixed reviews of her leadership.

Cavey took a leave of absence in late July. On Sept. 1, she submitted a resignation letter to board Chair M.G. Orender, effective Sept. 25. "It is with a heavy heart that I am submitting my resignation as Chief Executive Officer of JEA," she wrote, calling the decision "a deeply personal one."

Orender has defended her. He said she was unfairly targeted, credited her with helping identify roughly $80 million in budget savings that reduced the size of a rate increase, and noted that Moody's and Fitch improved JEA's bond ratings twice during her tenure. "JEA is better because of Vickie Cavey," Orender said in September. Mayor Donna Deegan said Cavey's role "became politicized" and called her "a wonderful public servant."

Council reaction

The pension figure drew sharp criticism from City Council Member Rory Diamond, a Republican. "Look, this is why Amendment 3 passed," Diamond told Action News Jax, referring to the statewide property tax measure voters approved Nov. 3. "Put police and fire aside, we absolutely need to reform bureaucrats' pensions."

Who is running JEA now

The JEA board unanimously selected Jody Brooks, the utility's chief administrative officer, as interim CEO and managing director on Sept. 25. Brooks has said her focus in the coming months will be affordability. Orender has said the board plans to hire a search firm and conduct an internal and external search for a permanent CEO, with no timeline set. Brooks may apply for the permanent job.

What's next

The Pension Board of Trustees is scheduled to take up Cavey's benefit at its Dec. 17 meeting. If the board ratifies the calculation, the plan would pay up to the federal limit, and JEA would then face the question of whether to cover the remainder through an excess benefit arrangement, a decision likely to draw further attention from the City Council as the utility searches for its next leader.

Spotted an issue with this article?

Have something to say about this story?

Write us a letter

Comments

Commenting is temporarily unavailable.

No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.

Related Coverage