Back to Florida News

Florida GOP Sues to Block Democratic Hope Florida Ad, Asks FDLE to Investigate 11 TV Stations Over Expunged Grand Jury Report

The Florida Press Newsroom7 min read
Orange-Osceola State Attorney Monique Worrell Opens Criminal Investigation Into Hope Florida Money Trail
Photo: State Attorney's Office for Florida's 9th Circuit Court, Wikimedia Commons (Public domain)

The Republican Party of Florida has gone to court to stop a Democratic television ad that cites the Hope Florida grand jury report, arguing that an appeals court's Oct. 7 order to expunge the report turned its contents into contraband that no one may broadcast. In a lawsuit filed late Friday, Oct. 16, in Highlands County circuit court, the party asked a judge to bar the ad without notice to the other side, and it separately asked the Florida Department of Law Enforcement and prosecutors to investigate 11 television stations in the Orlando and Tampa Bay markets, WUSF reported. The fight puts a 30-second campaign spot, the First Amendment and the state's top law enforcement officer, Attorney General James Uthmeier, at the center of the final two weeks before the Nov. 3 election.

As of Monday, no judge had ruled on the emergency request, and the defendants had not filed a response, according to WUSF.

The lawsuit and the ad

The case, Republican Party of Florida v. Florida Democratic Party, names the state Democratic Party, three Democratic statewide candidates and the owners of 11 stations. The candidates are David Jolly, the nominee for governor; Jose Javier Rodriguez, who is challenging Uthmeier for attorney general; and Annette Taddeo, the nominee for chief financial officer. Stations named include WFTV, WESH, WKMG and WOFL in Orlando and WTVT, WFLA, WTSP and WFTS in Tampa Bay, WUSF reported.

The ad, paid for by the Democratic Party and approved by the three candidates, says a leaked grand jury report found that taxpayer money was moved into a dark money committee controlled by Uthmeier and that $10 million was misappropriated. It closes with the words “conspiracy, concealment, corruption.”

The party argues that broadcasting the report's “content, gist, or import” violates Section 905.27 of the Florida Statutes, the grand jury secrecy law. A violation is a first-degree misdemeanor, which in Florida carries up to a year in jail, and the party also calls it criminal contempt of court. It asks for an immediate order blocking the ad, then temporary and permanent injunctions, a declaration that stations may not air the spot and Democrats may not place it, and an order covering any other material that relays the report's contents.

A letter from party lawyer Benjamin Gibson of Shutts & Bowen went to station managers the same day. Gibson wrote that knowingly airing ads built on the report's contents “is criminal conduct in Florida.” Copies went to FDLE Commissioner Larry Keefe, Statewide Prosecutor Brad McVay, who works in Uthmeier's office, and state attorneys in 11 of Florida's 20 judicial circuits.

Why Highlands County, and the free speech problem

Party Chair Evan Power said he did not know why the suit was filed in Highlands County. The complaint says venue is proper because the stations' signals reach the county and the ad is scheduled to air there. Asked whether the lawsuit was premature, Power said Democrats are “not going to change their minds.” The complaint calls its request “narrowly tailored” and argues that voters who act on the ad “can't recast” their ballots.

The suit faces significant legal obstacles. Federal law bars broadcasters from censoring ads placed by candidates, and a 1959 U.S. Supreme Court decision held that stations cannot be sued for libel over such ads. The complaint concedes that shield may block after-the-fact claims, which is why it seeks an injunction, and argues the federal protection does not extend to a state criminal secrecy law. In Butterworth v. Smith in 1990, the U.S. Supreme Court struck down part of Section 905.27, holding it could not be used to stop a grand jury witness from describing his own testimony after the grand jury's term ended. The party's complaint does not mention that ruling.

Attorney Andrea Flynn Mogensen told WUSF the relief sought would be an unlawful prior restraint. She said the First Amendment exists to keep the government from “silencing the press.”

The appeals court ruling

The lawsuit rests on an Oct. 7 opinion from the First District Court of Appeal ordering the 116-page grand jury presentment expunged “in its entirety.” Judge Lance Neff, whom Gov. Ron DeSantis appointed in March, wrote the 19-page opinion. He called the report “careless in its grammar” and “mistaken in its law,” and concluded that the $10 million “was never public money” because it went directly from Medicaid contractor Centene to the Hope Florida Foundation rather than to the state.

A footnote suggests that media publication of the report “may itself have violated” Section 905.27, a passage the Republican complaint relies on. But Neff also wrote that the court expressed no view on the lawfulness of publication by the press. Under court rules the ruling is not final until 15 days after it was entered or until any rehearing motions are resolved, so it could take effect as early as Friday, Oct. 23.

The court also turned on the prosecutor whose grand jury produced the report. It ordered Leon County State Attorney Jack Campbell to explain under oath, within five days, why it should not appoint a special master to investigate how the unredacted report reached the media and whether an injunction was violated. Campbell must also show cause why he should not be sanctioned or referred to The Florida Bar over an Aug. 26 email to lawyers for Uthmeier and others suggesting a clerk of the appeals court or the Leon County clerk was responsible for the leak. The opinion faulted Campbell for distributing the final report to unauthorized people in January.

The officials who fought to keep the report sealed were Uthmeier, Katie Strickland, Jason Weida and Andrew Sheeran, represented by private attorneys, WLRN reported. They won a confidentiality order on Aug. 25. The next day, CBS News Miami journalist Jim DeFede published an unredacted copy, and it has been public ever since.

How the Hope Florida saga began

The controversy dates to a September 2024 settlement with Centene, which paid $57 million to the state and $10 million to the Hope Florida Foundation, a charity tied to first lady Casey DeSantis's Hope Florida initiative, to resolve alleged Medicaid overpayments. The foundation gave the $10 million to two nonprofits, which donated it to Keep Florida Clean, a political committee led by Uthmeier, then DeSantis's chief of staff. The committee campaigned against the 2024 ballot measures on recreational marijuana and abortion rights, both of which failed.

State law requires notifying the Legislature when settlement talks begin, and lawmakers have said they learned of the deal only through press reports. Rep. Alex Andrade's House panel investigated the settlement in 2025, which led to a Leon County grand jury that heard testimony beginning in October 2025. The grand jury found the $10 million was “misappropriated” in what the appeals court described as a finding of a sophisticated scheme, but it brought no indictments, citing insufficient evidence.

DeSantis has called the matter a “hoax” and described the appeals ruling as “probably the biggest judicial smackdown” of his career. Uthmeier has denied wrongdoing, and his office has said the transfer was legal. Some Republicans have not let it go: U.S. Sen. Rick Scott called for a thorough investigation, and Byron Donalds, the Republican nominee for governor, has said lawmakers should pass reforms. Rodriguez has disputed the court's conclusion that the money was never public, pointing to reporting that the state counted the $10 million when calculating its Medicaid settlement obligations to the federal government. The administration says it did so out of an abundance of caution.

Other investigations still open

The expungement does not end every inquiry. Orange-Osceola State Attorney Monique Worrell is reviewing whether misappropriated money was spent in Central Florida, citing ads that ran in Orange and Osceola counties. She has said she will file charges only if she can prove a crime beyond a reasonable doubt. Uthmeier has called her effort a politically motivated witch hunt.

In a letter dated Oct. 16, Worrell said the board of the Florida Prosecuting Attorneys Association met to discuss her review and that a vote was sought to send DeSantis a letter admonishing her. She accused the group of acting as a mouthpiece for the governor and the attorney general and wrote that an investigation in one circuit does not stop another state attorney from examining crimes in her own. It was not clear from her letter whether a vote was taken. DeSantis suspended Worrell in 2023, and she won her seat back in 2024.

Separately, the IRS is reviewing a whistleblower claim filed by Andrade, and law enforcement is looking into how the report leaked. Jolly has pledged to reopen a fact-finding investigation if elected governor.

What's next

The immediate question is whether a Highlands County judge grants the Republican Party's request to pull the ad before the election, and whether any court would uphold such an order under the First Amendment. Stations and the Democratic defendants are expected to respond. The appeals ruling could become final as early as Oct. 23 unless a rehearing motion is filed, and Campbell's sworn answers on the leak and possible sanctions are due under the court's five-day deadline. Worrell's review, the IRS whistleblower claim and the leak investigation continue, and Uthmeier faces voters on Nov. 3 with the case still hanging over the attorney general's race.

Spotted an issue with this article?

Have something to say about this story?

Write us a letter

Comments

Commenting is temporarily unavailable.

No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.

Related Coverage