St. Thomas Aquinas Tackle Mark Matthews Aims to Become the First Offensive Lineman to Win the Nat Moore Trophy

St. Thomas Aquinas offensive tackle Mark Matthews is one of four finalists for the 2026 Nat Moore Trophy, CBS News Miami's award for the top high school football player in Miami-Dade, Broward and Monroe counties, and he would be the first offensive lineman ever to win it.
Matthews, a five-star prospect committed to the University of Georgia, is up against three University of Miami commits: North Miami Beach's Andre Hyppolite, Miami Carol City's Nicholas Lennear III and Christopher Columbus' A'mir Sears. Fan voting runs through Sunday, Nov. 29, and the winner will be named Dec. 1 at 7 p.m. during CBS News Miami's presentation show.
The race plays out in the middle of the postseason. Aquinas, the top seed in Florida's new Open Division, plays a must-win pool game at Venice on Friday, and Columbus and North Miami Beach are also still alive.
A lineman in a skill player's race
The Nat Moore Trophy has historically gone to players who touch the ball. Recent winners include Chaminade-Madonna running back Derrek Cooper in 2025, Malachi Toney in 2024, Jeremiah Smith, now an Ohio State wide receiver, in 2023, and Miami Central defensive end Rueben Bain Jr. in 2022, according to CBS News Miami.
Matthews' case rests on the work that makes those numbers possible. CBS News Miami reported that he helped clear the way for four different Aquinas running backs to score at least five touchdowns each this season. The station lists him at 300 pounds and between 6-foot-5 and 6-foot-6, describes him as one of the most highly regarded offensive tackles in the country, and notes that he has played the sport for only about three years and was a late bloomer to football.
"Football is a beautiful and complex game at the same time," Matthews told the station. Asked about his favorite moments, he described watching a running back score and celebrating with him. Of the South Florida talent pool, he said, "We're just a very hungry breed of people." He also credited his mother's cooking, naming oxtail and mac and cheese among his favorite meals.
A recruitment that ended in Athens
Matthews committed to Georgia on Nov. 9, one day after reopening his recruitment following nearly six months as a Texas A&M commitment, according to national recruiting coverage. He had first committed to the Aggies on May 15 over Georgia, Miami and LSU.
The Rivals Industry Rankings list him as the No. 2 overall prospect in the class of 2027, the No. 1 offensive tackle and the top-ranked player in Florida, according to Sports Illustrated's coverage of the commitment. Other services rank him slightly lower; ESPN lists him No. 6 overall and the No. 2 tackle in its 2027 rankings, according to the same reports.
The other three finalists
- Andre Hyppolite, North Miami Beach: A senior and four-star Miami commit who plays dual-threat quarterback and safety. CBS News Miami reported that he stepped in at quarterback when the starter was injured and, like Matthews, was a late bloomer who waited years for a varsity opportunity before drawing recruiting attention as a junior.
- Nicholas Lennear III, Miami Carol City: A five-star wide receiver and Miami commit known as "No Cut Nick" for his pact not to cut his hair during football season. He helped Miami Northwestern win a 2023 state championship before transferring to Carol City for his senior season, which the station said ended earlier than expected.
- A'mir "A1" Sears, Christopher Columbus: A two-way athlete who reclassified from the class of 2028 to 2027 and committed to Miami this summer. CBS News Miami calls him the nation's top-rated athlete in the 2027 class.
How the winner is picked
The finalists were announced Tuesday, Nov. 10, during CBS News Miami's 7 p.m. newscast. Fan voting counts for 10% of the decision, and a selection panel decides the rest, according to the station. The award weighs athletic excellence, leadership, character, academics and sportsmanship.
The trophy is named for Nat Moore, the wide receiver who played 13 seasons for the Miami Dolphins from 1974 to 1986 and remains active in South Florida community and charitable work. It is sponsored by FPL.
Aquinas' Open Division stakes
Aquinas enters Friday at 10-1 after its first loss of the season, a 27-24 overtime defeat to Lakeland on Nov. 13 in the first game of the FHSAA's inaugural Open Division. The eight-team division, seeded from the final MaxPreps rankings regardless of classification, splits teams into two pools of four. A loss does not end a team's season: each team plays the three others in its pool, and the top two in each pool advance to the semifinals.
That makes Friday's trip to No. 8 Venice (9-2, 0-1) close to an elimination game for the No. 1 seed. Venice lost its pool opener 35-0 at No. 4 Chaminade-Madonna. The loser of Friday's game will need a lot of help to reach the semifinals, Yahoo Sports reported. The game at Venice's Powell-Davis Stadium was listed for a 7:30 p.m. kickoff. In the other Pool A game, No. 5 Lakeland (10-1, 1-0) visits Chaminade-Madonna (9-2, 1-0) with first place on the line.
Columbus, the No. 2 seed, is 10-1 and 1-0 in Pool B after beating Miami Central in its opener. The Explorers make their longest trip of the season Friday to No. 7 Raines in Jacksonville. If Columbus and No. 3 West Boca Raton both win Friday, both will clinch semifinal spots, according to Yahoo Sports.
The Open Division semifinals are scheduled for Dec. 5 at The Range at H.G. Morse Stadium in Sumterville, and the first Open Division championship is set for Dec. 12 at South Dade Kia Field at Pitbull Stadium on Florida International University's campus.
North Miami Beach (8-3) is in the Class 3A bracket. After a 27-10 win at Glades Central in the regional quarterfinals, the Chargers are listed to play at Cardinal Gibbons in Fort Lauderdale in a regional semifinal Friday at 7 p.m.
Flooding hangs over Friday
The games come at the end of a week of historic rain in South Florida. Broward County Public Schools closed Wednesday and Thursday, and Miami-Dade County Public Schools closed Thursday and canceled activities and athletic events for the day. Broward County declared a countywide state of emergency, and rain totals over 72 hours topped 15 inches in Sunrise, Hollywood and Plantation, according to CBS News Miami.
As of Thursday, neither district had said whether schools would reopen Friday, and the Archdiocese of Miami was deciding closures school by school. No postponement of Friday's games involving the finalists' teams had been reported as of Thursday, and conditions were forecast to improve Friday. The Aquinas and Columbus games are on the road, at Venice and Jacksonville, well outside the flooded area.
What's next
Voting closes Nov. 29, two days before the Dec. 1 announcement. By then Aquinas will know whether it has reached the Open Division semifinals, and whether Matthews, a member of the class of 2027, still has a shot at a state title in Miami on Dec. 12.
Spotted an issue with this article?
Have something to say about this story?
Write us a letterComments
No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.
Related Coverage

Sam O'Reilly Scores His First NHL Goal and Jake Guentzel Adds Two as Lightning Beat Capitals 5-2
28m ago

Miami Holds at No. 7 and Florida Enters at No. 24 in the Third College Football Playoff Rankings
1h ago

Giannis Antetokounmpo Nearly Posts a Triple-Double Against His Former Team as Heat Beat Bucks 137-130 on Vice City Night
4h ago

Urban Klavzar Scores Career-High 24 as No. 1 Florida Beats Notre Dame 86-78 After Boogie Fland Exits With Shoulder Injury
23h ago