Doral Voter Sues DeSantis in Florida Supreme Court to Force Special Election for Vacant Senate District 39

A Doral voter backed by the ACLU of Florida asked the Florida Supreme Court on Tuesday, Nov. 17, to order Gov. Ron DeSantis to call a special election for Senate District 39, a Miami-Dade County seat that has been empty for 84 days since Republican Sen. Bryan Ávila resigned to run for lieutenant governor. The petition argues that state law gives the governor no choice about whether to schedule an election, and that roughly half a million residents of Hialeah, Doral, Sweetwater and Miami Lakes are about to head into the 2027 legislative cycle with no senator.
It is the latest in a string of lawsuits accusing DeSantis of sitting on legislative and congressional vacancies. The ACLU says this is the 10th vacancy since 2021 for which voters have had to go to court to force an election, and that in nearly every earlier case the governor set dates only after being sued.
What the lawsuit asks for
The petition, filed on behalf of Alejandro Peñuela, a registered voter who lives in the district, seeks a writ of mandamus, an order directing a public official to carry out a duty the law requires. It relies on Section 100.111(2) of the Florida Statutes, which says that when a legislative seat becomes vacant, the governor, after consulting the secretary of state, "shall fix the dates" of a special primary and special general election.
Peñuela's lawyers argue that the word "shall" leaves DeSantis no discretion and that he "has a clear and indisputable legal duty" to act. The petition asks the justices to order an election "as soon as possible" but does not propose specific dates, and it asks for expedited review, according to the Florida Phoenix and WLRN.
Peñuela said the governor's refusal "denies us our right to representation," according to WLRN.
An empty seat since August
Ávila's resignation took effect Aug. 25, when he left the Senate to join Byron Donalds' ticket as the Republican candidate for lieutenant governor. Donalds won the governor's race on Nov. 3, and he and Ávila are scheduled to be sworn in on Jan. 5.
Ávila won the district in 2024 by nearly 40 percentage points, and the seat was previously held by Republican Sen. Anitere Flores, the Phoenix reported. With no special election on the calendar, the district had no senator when the Legislature convened its organization session in Tallahassee on the same day the suit was filed, and it will have none when interim committee weeks begin on Nov. 30, 13 days later.
The ACLU argues the delay is also costing money. Had DeSantis acted promptly after Ávila's resignation, the group says, a special primary or general election could have been held alongside municipal elections already scheduled for late November or December. Holding a standalone election later is likely to cost taxpayers more, the ACLU contends.
'As perplexing as it is illegal'
Nicholas Warren, a senior staff attorney at the ACLU of Florida, said the governor's refusal to call the election is "as perplexing as it is illegal." He contrasted DeSantis with his predecessors, saying governors from Jeb Bush to Rick Scott "consistently acted quickly" when seats came open, often calling special elections within days.
"There is no good reason for this governor to keep resisting timely special elections," Warren said, according to the Phoenix.
The lawsuit describes the length of the current vacancy without an election call as "longer than any of his predecessors in known history." The governor's office had not responded to requests for comment by the time the suit was reported, according to the Tallahassee Democrat.
A pattern of lawsuits
Voters and the ACLU have repeatedly gone to court over vacancies during DeSantis's two terms, and the governor has typically set an election soon after a suit landed. Earlier cases involved seats in Tampa, Palm Beach County, Northwest Florida, Brevard County, Miami-Dade County and Broward County, according to WLRN. The cases include:
| Year | Vacancy at issue | What followed |
|---|---|---|
| 2021 | U.S. Rep. Alcee Hastings' South Florida congressional seat and vacant legislative seats | Special elections called after suits; legislative case dropped |
| 2023 | Miami-Dade state House seat | Election date set after suit |
| Jan. 2025 | Senate District 19 (Brevard) and House District 3 (Panhandle) | DeSantis set elections; ACLU dropped case |
| Sept. 2025 | Senate District 14 (Hillsborough) | Special election held in March 2026 |
| Nov. 2026 | Senate District 39 (Miami-Dade) | Pending at Florida Supreme Court |
The Hillsborough case is the closest parallel. That seat opened when DeSantis chose then-Sen. Jay Collins as lieutenant governor in 2025, and when the special election was finally held in March 2026, Democrat Brian Nathan flipped it, beating Republican state Rep. Josie Tomkow by 408 votes. The 2025 Brevard and Panhandle vacancies were created when Republican lawmakers resigned to run for Congress, and the ACLU dismissed that suit after DeSantis issued executive orders setting the elections.
Why the seat matters
Senate District 39 is safely Republican on paper, but the timing of its special election has practical consequences in a Senate where Republicans no longer hold a two-thirds supermajority after the November midterms. Every vote counts more on measures that require a two-thirds threshold, and a vacant seat is one fewer vote for the majority.
For residents, the stakes are more immediate. The interim committee weeks that begin Nov. 30 are when lawmakers start shaping bills for the 60-day regular session that opens March 2, and the lawsuit says the district's half a million constituents lack representation through that stretch. It also says Peñuela's vote is effectively being denied twice: once through the empty seat and again through the delay.
What's next
The Florida Supreme Court must decide whether to take up the petition and, if so, how quickly. In past cases the question became moot when the governor set election dates after being sued, and the ACLU dropped its complaints once he did. If DeSantis follows that pattern, the dates he sets will determine whether the district's new senator can be seated in time for the March 2 session.
DeSantis leaves office on Jan. 5. If he has not called the election by then, the decision will pass to Donalds, whose own running mate is the senator who left the seat open.
Spotted an issue with this article?
Have something to say about this story?
Write us a letterComments
No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.
Related Coverage

Doral Councilwoman Maureen Porras Keeps Pushing to Revisit City's ICE 287(g) Pact After City Attorney Blocks the Item
1d ago

Garrison and Boyd Take the Gavels, All but Rule Out DeSantis's Pre-January Special Session on Amendment 3
2d ago

Brett Moss Sworn In as Key Biscayne Mayor After Voters Reject the Big Dig Stormwater Plan
2d ago

Miami Moves to Gut LGBTQ Advisory Board and Repeal Affirmative Action Ahead of Florida DEI Ban
2d ago