Back to Florida News

Four More Arrested, Including Three State Employees, in $1.7 Million Florida Property Damage Claims Fraud Case; Total Reaches 37

The Florida Press Newsroom5 min read
Four More Arrested, Including Three State Employees, in $1.7 Million Florida Property Damage Claims Fraud Case; Total Reaches 37
Photo via FOX 13 Tampa Bay

Four more people, three of them current state employees, were arrested in Gadsden County on Tuesday, Nov. 17, in a fraud investigation that Florida officials say drained $1.7 million in taxpayer money through bogus property damage claims, Chief Financial Officer Blaise Ingoglia announced. The case now totals 37 arrests, including 17 state employees, according to the Florida Department of Financial Services.

The investigation is run by the department's Criminal Investigations Division. It centers on claims paid through the Florida Division of Risk Management, the office within the department that administers the state's self-insurance program for state agencies. All of those arrested are charged, not convicted, and are presumed innocent.

The latest arrests

According to the department's Nov. 17 release, the four people arrested are Damien Chapman, Nikia Pender, Devecchio Sailor and Veronica Chapman. The release identifies Damien Chapman, Pender and Sailor as state employees but does not say which agencies employ them. All four are charged with grand theft and cashing an item with intent to defraud.

The department's announcement was titled as a scheme that "continues to unravel," and it described the new arrests as part of the same investigation that began with McCarthy's arrest in February.

"We will pursue every investigative lead to uncovering every person involved in stealing from the taxpayers," Ingoglia said in the release.

How investigators say the scheme worked

The case began with Briana McCarthy, a former Department of Financial Services employee arrested in February. Investigators say she processed more than 220 suspicious property damage claims through the Division of Risk Management for family members and acquaintances, resulting in about $1.7 million in fraudulent payouts.

The department has not publicly described what kind of damage the claims reported or how the payments were routed. The charges filed so far follow a pattern: most defendants are accused of grand theft and of cashing or depositing checks with intent to defraud, while a smaller group faces organized scheme to defraud charges.

McCarthy faces the longest list of charges: grand theft, aggravated white collar crime, money laundering, scheme to defraud, criminal use of personal identification information, communications fraud, official misconduct and forgery.

Arrests over nine months

The department has announced the arrests in waves since February. The rounds named in its public releases are below.

AnnouncedArrestsWho and what
Feb. 96McCarthy and five others, including two former Department of Business and Professional Regulation employees
Feb. 134Grand theft and check cashing charges; total reached 10
Sept. 287Booked in Leon and Polk counties in August; total passed 30
Nov. 174Three state employees arrested in Gadsden County; total reached 37

The four rounds account for 21 named defendants. The department's running total of 37 indicates additional arrests between those announcements that were not detailed in the releases reviewed for this story.

Who has been charged

The February 9 group included Brianna Hannan, a former Department of Business and Professional Regulation employee, and Kearia Walker and Kavon Reese, each charged with grand theft. Carlotta Hawkins, also a former DBPR employee, and Whitney Branch were charged with grand theft and cashing or depositing an item with intent to defraud.

The Feb. 9 release said additional arrests were "expected to be made in the coming weeks." Four days later, on Feb. 13, the department announced the arrests of Shelton Allen, Latasha Belford and Ni'jah Johnson, charged with grand theft and cashing or depositing an item with intent to defraud, and Cervantes Galloway, charged with grand theft.

The September announcement covered seven people. Six were booked into the Leon County Jail on Aug. 19, and one into the Polk County jail on Aug. 21. According to the department, their charges and maximum possible sentences are:

DefendantChargesMaximum
Tyler FrisonOrganized scheme to defraud, grand theft, cashing an item with intent to defraud15 years
D'Andrea Campbell-FrisonOrganized scheme to defraud, grand theft10 years
Deidra CampbellGrand theft, unlawful use of a two-way communication device10 years
Khadijah CampbellGrand theft, cashing an item with intent to defraud10 years
Mona WoodGrand theft, cashing an item with intent to defraud10 years
Jennifer YoungOrganized scheme to defraud, grand theft, cashing an item with intent to defraud15 years
Jacoby WoodGrand theft, cashing an item with intent to defraud, unlawful use of a two-way communication device15 years

The CFO's message

Ingoglia has framed the case as part of a broader push against waste and fraud in state government. When the first arrests were announced in February, he said, "Let me be crystal clear: if you steal from Florida taxpayers, you will go to jail," and added, "As CFO, I will not allow waste, fraud, and abuse of taxpayer dollars to be left unchecked." He repeated the warning that thieves "will go to jail" in the department's Feb. 13 announcement of four more arrests. In September, he said, "Defrauding the state and abusing taxpayer dollars is dead on arrival in Florida," adding that "there is no safe haven for these criminals and every person involved will be brought to justice."

The case is notable for how many people inside state government it has reached. With three more current employees charged this week, 17 of the 37 people arrested are state employees, according to the department. When the department announced the September round, it counted 14 former state employees among those arrested; the Nov. 17 release is the first to describe defendants as current state workers, and it does not say whether they remain on the job. Arrests announced so far have been booked in Leon, Polk and Gadsden counties.

What's next

Officials have not said how many more arrests they expect or whether any money has been recovered. The department has not publicly reported whether any of the earlier defendants have resolved their cases in court. Ingoglia's office said investigators are continuing to pursue others who may be connected to the alleged scheme.

When the investigation went public in February, the department said all state agencies were fully cooperating and asked anyone with information about the scheme to contact the Criminal Investigations Division at (850) 508-7827. The charges against each defendant will proceed separately in circuit court, where prosecutors must prove each element, including intent to defraud, for every person charged.

Spotted an issue with this article?

Have something to say about this story?

Write us a letter

Comments

Commenting is temporarily unavailable.

No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.

Related Coverage