Jacksonville Judge Gives Four Consecutive Life Sentences in 1985 Christmas Eve Killing of Teen Leslie McCray, Answering Her Late Father's Wish

A Duval County judge on Wednesday, Nov. 18, sentenced David Nelson Austin, 65, to four consecutive life sentences for the 1985 kidnapping, sexual assault and murder of 17-year-old Leslie McCray, closing a Jacksonville cold case that her father did not live to see solved. Circuit Judge Meredith Charbula imposed the sentences about a month after finding Austin guilty on all counts in a bench trial, according to News4JAX.
McCray was abducted at knifepoint from her St. Johns Avenue duplex in the early hours of Christmas Eve 1985. Her killer went unidentified for nearly 41 years, until retested DNA evidence pointed investigators to a man who had once lived in the same duplex and who had been serving a life sentence in Michigan since 1991.
The sentence
At the Nov. 18 hearing, Charbula first denied a defense motion for a new trial, News4JAX reported. She then imposed a mandatory life sentence on the first-degree murder conviction. Because the crime happened in 1985, that sentence is governed by the law in effect at the time, which carried parole review after 25 years. The judge then added three more life sentences, one for each of the remaining convictions on two counts of armed kidnapping and one count of armed sexual battery, and ordered all four to run consecutively.
The stacked sentences make any release from Florida custody a remote prospect. Austin also remains under the life sentence he was already serving in Michigan for separate sexual assault convictions.
A father's dying wish
McCray's father, Glen McCray, died in 2003 at age 62 without learning who killed his daughter. In a statement read in court, his sister, Iris Skeen, said, "It was his dying wish that we continue to look for the person who took her from us."
The family kept that promise. Relatives worked with the nonprofit Project: Cold Case to press for the case to be reopened, first in 2003 and again in 2019, according to News4JAX. The 2003 retesting did not produce usable results. The second request did.
What happened on Christmas Eve 1985
According to the account presented at trial, an intruder entered the duplex McCray shared with a 20-year-old roommate, bound the roommate and took McCray away. She was sexually assaulted at knifepoint and stabbed. Her body was found hours later in a ravine along Old Middleburg Road.
The roommate survived. For years, police focused on him and questioned his account of the attack, News4JAX reported. Now 61, he testified at Austin's trial about what happened that night.
How DNA broke the case
In 2019, the Jacksonville Sheriff's Office Cold Case Unit retested evidence preserved from 1985, work funded by a U.S. Justice Department grant, according to News4JAX. Investigators developed a DNA profile from a swab taken during the sexual assault examination at McCray's autopsy.
That profile did two things. It cleared the roommate, and it led detectives to Austin, who had previously lived in the same duplex on St. Johns Avenue. Detectives later obtained Austin's DNA in Michigan, where he was in prison, and it matched the 1985 swab. A Duval County grand jury indicted him on a first-degree murder charge in August 2021.
McCray's relatives credited Cold Case Detective Harmoni Brooks after the verdict. A cousin, Joey Bray, told News4JAX that Brooks answered whenever the family called or emailed and traveled to Perry, Florida, to walk relatives through the case.
The trial and verdict
The State Attorney's Office for the Fourth Judicial Circuit waived the death penalty before trial, an agreement that allowed the case to be heard by a judge instead of a jury, News4JAX reported. Bench trials are uncommon in first-degree murder cases.
Assistant State Attorney Lauren Anderson prosecuted the case. The evidence was circumstantial, and there were no eyewitnesses to the killing itself. Defense attorney Joshua Beard argued that the roommate could have been responsible. Austin did not testify, and the defense called no witnesses.
On Oct. 22, Charbula found Austin guilty of first-degree murder, two counts of armed kidnapping and armed sexual battery. Outside the courtroom that day, Bray told News4JAX, "I wanted to jump up when she said guilty on the first charge and just shout, 'Hallelujah!'" She added, "He's going to be held accountable; thank the Lord."
Anderson credited the family for keeping the case alive. "It is a blessing that the family was persistent," she said, adding that the outcome was "a huge message to never give up, to push the investigators." Assistant State Attorney Chyna Makarowski thanked Project: Cold Case and the Jacksonville Sheriff's Office for their work. The surviving roommate said he was "grateful for the evidence that led to this guilty verdict," according to News4JAX.
Austin speaks of faith
Austin addressed the court at sentencing. According to News4JAX, he expressed sympathy to McCray's family and described the Christian faith he said was renewed in a Michigan prison in 1993, which he said now shapes the mentoring he does with other incarcerated men. The statement came after the verdict; he had not testified during the trial.
Timeline of the case
The case stretched across four decades, according to News4JAX reporting on the trial and sentencing.
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| Dec. 24, 1985 | McCray abducted from her duplex and killed |
| 1991 | Austin begins life sentence in Michigan for separate sexual assaults |
| 2003 | Evidence retested without usable results; Glen McCray dies |
| 2019 | Retesting yields DNA profile, clears roommate, points to Austin |
| August 2021 | Austin indicted on first-degree murder charge |
| Oct. 22, 2026 | Found guilty on all four counts in bench trial |
| Nov. 18, 2026 | Sentenced to four consecutive life terms |
Why the case was solvable
The outcome depended on evidence collected in 1985, decades before modern DNA analysis existed, being preserved and still usable in 2019. A federal grant paid for the testing, and a nonprofit kept the family connected to investigators. The same testing that identified Austin also cleared the roommate, who had lived for decades under suspicion without ever being charged.
What's next
With the motion for a new trial denied and the sentences imposed, Austin may appeal his convictions to Florida's appellate courts. No appeal had been reported as of Thursday. His Michigan sentence remains in force regardless of the outcome of any Florida appeal.
For McCray's family, the sentencing closes a search that outlived her father by more than two decades. Skeen thanked Project: Cold Case, the prosecutors and everyone who worked the case after the verdict in October.
Spotted an issue with this article?
Have something to say about this story?
Write us a letterComments
No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.
Related Coverage

Four More Arrested, Including Three State Employees, in $1.7 Million Florida Property Damage Claims Fraud Case; Total Reaches 37
1h ago

Osceola Man Accused of Plotting From Jail to Have Child Witness Killed
1d ago

Baker County Jury Acquits 2 Men in Macclenny Stand Your Ground Shooting Case
2d ago

Osceola deputy fatally shoots woman the sheriff says pointed a gun at a man outside an Old Town Kissimmee bar
2d ago