Back to Florida News

Byron Donalds Warns Tallahassee 'Full Stop' as New City Commission Moves Toward Exiting ICE 287(g) Deal

The Florida Press Newsroom6 min read
Byron Donalds Warns Tallahassee 'Full Stop' as New City Commission Moves Toward Exiting ICE 287(g) Deal
Photo via Yahoo News

Gov.-elect Byron Donalds put Florida's capital city on notice Thursday, Nov. 19, one day after the newly seated Tallahassee City Commission voted to take up whether its police department should leave its immigration enforcement partnership with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. In a post on X, Donalds wrote that Florida is not a sanctuary state and that, as governor, he will never let it become one, adding that Florida cities must comply with federal and state laws, full stop.

Attorney General James Uthmeier quickly backed him, signaling that the state's next administration intends to keep the same hard line on local immigration cooperation that Gov. Ron DeSantis and Uthmeier have enforced against cities from Key West to Fort Myers. Tallahassee has not ended its agreement. What it has done is schedule a debate on how it could.

What Tallahassee actually voted on

At its meeting on the night of Wednesday, Nov. 18, the commission voted 5-0 to place an item on its next agenda laying out a framework for possibly withdrawing from the Tallahassee Police Department's 287(g) agreement with ICE, according to Newsweek. The vote does not end the agreement, and no final vote has been scheduled.

Mayor Pro Tem Jacqueline "Jack" Porter made the motion. Newsweek quoted her saying: I'm ready to move forward to exit the 287(g) agreement. Mayor Jeremy Matlow argued that state law never required the city to sign the agreement in the first place. WFSU quoted him calling it pretty clear we didn't have a mandate.

Not every commissioner sounded eager. Commissioner Dianne Williams-Cox warned colleagues about the state's enforcement tools, telling them, according to Newsweek: They may not have mandated it, but there are penalties.

Police Chief Lawrence Revell described the department's role as limited. He told commissioners that one officer has received the training and has access to an immigration enforcement database, according to Newsweek, adding: That's our level of involvement.

A new commission, a new direction

The vote reflects a sharp change at City Hall. Matlow, a longtime critic of the ICE agreement who previously held the commission's Seat 3, was sworn in as mayor on Nov. 16, according to WFSU. The five-member commission now consists of Matlow, Porter, Williams-Cox, Curtis Richardson and newcomer PJ Perez.

At the same Nov. 18 meeting, the commission voted 3-2 to fire City Manager Karen Jumonville, with Richardson and Williams-Cox dissenting, WFSU reported. Deputy City Attorney Lou Norvell was named interim city manager. Jumonville has retained an attorney, and the city attorney warned the decision could expose the city to a breach-of-contract claim because her contract calls for four votes to terminate.

The ICE question has been building in Tallahassee for well over a year. The agreement was executed in 2025 by the city manager and police chief as an administrative action, without a commission vote, according to WFSU and WTXL reporting at the time. After months of public protest, the previous commission voted 3-2 in October 2025 to keep it, with then-Mayor John Dailey, Williams-Cox and Richardson voting against rescinding it. Porter and Matlow were on the losing side.

The state's response

Uthmeier, who like Donalds won election this month, answered Donalds' post by pointing to a letter his office sent the city of Doral on Wednesday, Nov. 18, over a similar move there. According to News 6 in Orlando, Uthmeier wrote that supporting federal partners and protecting the state's sovereignty is not optional, it is the law.

The Doral letter, signed by Deputy Attorney General Greg Slemp and addressed to Doral Mayor Christi Fraga, argued that rescinding a 287(g) agreement without sufficient justification could demonstrate a sanctuary policy, News 6 reported. Newsweek reported that Uthmeier said walking back from an agreement would demonstrate forbidden sanctuary policies.

That framing matters because Florida law bans sanctuary policies, and the state has repeatedly said local officials who adopt them can face civil penalties and removal from office by the governor.

Is a city required to have a 287(g) agreement?

The legal question at the center of the dispute is not settled in the way either side would like. News 6 noted that Florida law does not necessarily require local governments to sign 287(g) agreements. Legislation passed during a February 2025 special session placed greater obligations on local governments and requires operators of county jails to enter the agreements, but it does not spell out the same requirement for city police departments, according to WUSF's reporting on a South Miami lawsuit over the issue.

The state's position has been that a city's refusal can still be evidence of a sanctuary policy. In that South Miami case, the attorney general's office argued that a municipality's failure to execute a 287(g) agreement can reveal a sanctuary policy, especially alongside other facts. A Leon County circuit judge dismissed South Miami's lawsuit with prejudice in September 2025 without resolving whether cities must join, leaving local officials without a court ruling to rely on.

A pattern of pressure

Tallahassee would not be the first Florida city to test the state on this question. The table below shows how earlier disputes played out.

City or countyYearWhat happened
Fort Myers2025Council reversed course and approved an agreement after an Uthmeier letter
Key West2025Commission voted to void its agreement, then reversed after a removal threat
Orange County2025Mayor Jerry Demings signed an addendum on transporting detainees after state demands
Tampa2026Uthmeier accused police policies of creating a sanctuary policy and threatened Mayor Jane Castor with removal
Doral2026State warned in a Nov. 18 letter that rescinding its agreement could be a sanctuary policy

In the Orange County episode, Uthmeier told News 6 that any local government effort to impede law enforcement's ability to assist the federal government in immigration enforcement is per se a sanctuary jurisdiction.

Why Donalds weighed in now

Donalds, a Republican congressman from Southwest Florida, defeated Democrat David Jolly in a close Nov. 3 race and is set to take office on Jan. 5, 2027. His campaign website lists law and order as a central issue and calls for coordinating state and local police directly with federal authorities to deport noncitizens who commit crimes, according to Newsweek.

The post on Tallahassee was his clearest signal yet that he intends to carry forward DeSantis' approach to sanctuary policies. It also landed in a city he will soon govern from: the state Capitol sits inside the city limits of the government whose police agreement is now in question. As governor, Donalds would hold the suspension power that state officials have cited in their warnings to local leaders.

What's next

The Tallahassee commission is expected to take up the framework for a possible withdrawal at its next meeting; Newsweek did not report a date. Any decision to actually terminate the agreement would require a further vote. If the city moves ahead, the experience of Key West and Fort Myers suggests a formal demand letter from the attorney general's office is likely, and the dispute could stretch into the opening weeks of the Donalds administration in January. Doral's response to the Nov. 18 letter will offer an early indication of how far cities are willing to push back.

Spotted an issue with this article?

Have something to say about this story?

Write us a letter

Comments

Commenting is temporarily unavailable.

No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.

Related Coverage