Back to Florida News

Federal Judge Rules Florida's Form 6 Financial Disclosure Law for Local Officials Unconstitutional

The Florida Press Newsroom5 min read
Federal Judge Rules Florida's Form 6 Financial Disclosure Law for Local Officials Unconstitutional
Photo via WLRN

A federal judge has ruled that key parts of Florida's 2023 law requiring mayors, city commissioners and other municipal elected officials to file the state's most detailed financial disclosure form are unconstitutional, siding with 175 local officials who argued the mandate violated their First Amendment rights. The decision by U.S. District Judge Melissa Damian, in an order dated Nov. 9 and reported on Nov. 18, sets the stage for a permanent injunction that would make the law's expanded disclosure requirements unenforceable across the state.

The law, SB 774, required local officers and candidates to file Form 6, the full financial disclosure that state lawmakers and statewide officials already file, instead of the far less detailed Form 1 that municipal officials had long used. Form 6 calls for an official's precise net worth and any source of income over $1,000. The change prompted a wave of resignations in city halls statewide, with more than 100 elected officials reportedly stepping down rather than comply.

What the judge decided

Damian, a Fort Lauderdale-based judge in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida, found that the law compelled officials to disclose information they otherwise would not have revealed, infringing on their First Amendment rights, according to WLRN, which first reported the ruling. She wrote that disclosure requirements, both those that require reporting to the government and those that require disclosure directly to the public, are subject to First Amendment scrutiny, and noted that the information collected on the form would be publicly available.

"The mandated disclosures at issue involve detailed personal financial information of public, elected officials," the order states, as quoted by WLRN.

The court had already blocked enforcement of SB 774 while the lawsuit moved forward. The judge now plans to issue a permanent injunction, and the parties must meet with her before the end of November to work out its terms.

What SB 774 required

The Florida Commission on Ethics pushed for the legislation to increase transparency in local government finances and to align the rules for municipal officials with those that already apply to state constitutional officers and legislators. The Legislature passed the bill in 2023, and the Form 6 requirement for municipal officials took effect on Jan. 1, 2024.

Form 6 covers an official's net worth, income sources and assets over $1,000, and the detailed form had previously applied to state lawmakers and other state-level officials, according to News 6 in Orlando. Members of Congress do not file it. Before the law, mayors and city commissioners filed the less detailed Form 1.

During the 2024 legislative session, lawmakers rejected a proposal that would have delayed the requirement to 2025 and exempted communities with 500 or fewer residents, News 6 reported. Rep. Spencer Roach, a Republican who led the effort to keep the law intact, described it at the time as an issue of transparency.

The officials who sued

Local officials filed the federal lawsuit in February 2024, and the group of plaintiffs grew to 175 municipal officers from around the state. Their lead attorney, Jamie A. Cole of the firm Weiss Serota Helfman Cole and Bierman, argued that the state was compelling speech in violation of the First Amendment without showing that the less intrusive Form 1 had failed.

Among the named plaintiffs are Joshua Simmons, a former Coral Springs commissioner, and Fortuna Smukler, a North Miami Beach commissioner. Smukler told WLRN that it was enough that officials' lives are already a public record, and she and other opponents raised concerns that publishing detailed asset information could make officials targets for burglary. Simmons said the law would discourage people from running for local office, while agreeing that transparency in government matters.

A wave of resignations

Estimates of the number of officials who resigned rather than file Form 6 vary. WLRN reported that more than 100 elected officials stepped down after the bill passed, and News 6 and the plaintiffs' attorney put the figure at about 125 in the months before the first filing deadline.

Some local governments lost most or all of their elected leadership. News 6 reported that the entire Reddick town council in Marion County resigned in December 2023, and that council members in Orange City and Daytona Beach Shores also stepped down. Other cities, such as New Smyrna Beach, joined the legal challenge.

How the case got here

The litigation has moved slowly since the first ruling in 2024. The following timeline shows the major steps, based on reporting by News 6, WLRN and WUSF.

DateEvent
2023Legislature passes SB 774, extending Form 6 to municipal officials
Jan. 1, 2024Form 6 requirement for municipal officials takes effect
February 2024Local officials file federal lawsuit
June 2024Damian issues preliminary injunction weeks before the July 1 filing deadline
Nov. 9, 2026Damian rules parts of the law unconstitutional
By end of November 2026Parties meet with the judge on terms of a permanent injunction

In the June 2024 preliminary injunction, Damian found the law likely violated the First Amendment. She wrote that the state "failed to establish that the state seriously undertook the consideration of less intrusive means," and pointed to "the absence of any evidence, data, or studies" showing that Form 1 had been inadequate, according to News 6. Both sides in the case agreed that deterring corruption, increasing transparency and avoiding conflicts of interest are compelling state interests; the dispute was over whether Form 6 was a properly tailored way to pursue them. The state did not appeal that preliminary ruling, News 6 reported.

The state's response

The Florida Commission on Ethics, the defendant in the case, declined WLRN's request for comment, citing the ongoing litigation. WLRN's report did not indicate whether the state plans to appeal the final ruling to the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. Earlier in the case, the Attorney General's office had signaled it would recommend an appeal if the law were ultimately struck down, according to 2024 local news coverage of the commission's litigation updates.

What it means for local officials and what's next

For now, municipal officials across Florida remain shielded from the Form 6 mandate, as they have been since the 2024 injunction. Once Damian enters a permanent injunction, the expanded disclosure requirement for local officials would be unenforceable unless the ruling is overturned on appeal or the Legislature rewrites the law in a way that survives First Amendment review.

The next step is the conference with the judge before the end of the month to settle the injunction's terms. Any appeal by the state, and any attempt by lawmakers to revisit local financial disclosure rules when the Legislature next convenes, would determine whether the issue that emptied some town halls in 2023 and 2024 returns.

Spotted an issue with this article?

Have something to say about this story?

Write us a letter

Comments

Commenting is temporarily unavailable.

No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.

Related Coverage