Back to Florida News

Former Plastic Surgeon Tomasz Kosowski Sentenced to Death for Murder of Largo Attorney Steven Cozzi

The Florida Press Newsroom6 min read
Former Plastic Surgeon Tomasz Kosowski Sentenced to Death for Murder of Largo Attorney Steven Cozzi
Photo via FOX 13 Tampa Bay

A Pinellas County judge on Friday sentenced former plastic surgeon Tomasz Kosowski to death for the March 2023 murder of Largo attorney Steven Cozzi, who vanished from his law office and whose body has never been found. Pinellas Circuit Judge Joseph Bulone, who convicted Kosowski of first-degree murder at a bench trial in September, imposed the sentence at a hearing in Clearwater after finding that the killing was cold, calculated and premeditated.

"The court concludes that the defendant, under the laws of the State of Florida, has forfeited his right to live," Bulone said, according to the Associated Press.

The sentence

Bulone had two options under Florida law: death or life in prison without the possibility of release. In announcing his decision, the judge said he gave "great weight" to the aggravating factor that the homicide was committed in a "cold, calculated and premeditated manner, without any pretense of moral or legal justification," FOX 13 reported. He gave "moderate weight" to a second aggravating factor, that the murder was committed at least in part for financial gain.

The judge found several mitigating factors but said none outweighed the aggravating factors, and that the cold, calculated and premeditated factor alone outweighed all of the mitigation. At the guilt phase, Bulone had found two of the three aggravating factors prosecutors alleged proven beyond a reasonable doubt; he did not find that the murder was especially heinous, atrocious or cruel.

Before the sentence was read, Kosowski, who represented himself throughout the case, raised a new motion. "Motion to disqualify Joseph Bulone," he said, according to FOX 13. The judge reviewed the motion for about 15 minutes and then proceeded with sentencing.

Bulone appointed the public defender's office to handle Kosowski's appeals, the AP reported.

A courtroom in bow ties

Many of Cozzi's family members and friends wore bow ties to court in tribute to him, as they had at earlier hearings. FOX 13 reported that some nodded in approval and some exhaled in relief when the sentence was announced. Speaking off camera afterward, Cozzi's parents and his husband said they were relieved and are focused on honoring his memory.

After the September verdict, Cozzi's father, George Cozzi, said "a very evil person was taken off the streets." His husband, Michael Montgomery, said then: "I know there was nothing I could've done, but grief doesn't allow logic to prevail."

What prosecutors said happened

Cozzi, a lawyer at the Blanchard Law Firm in Largo, disappeared from the office on March 21, 2023. He left behind his phone, keys and wallet, and a work file was still open on his computer.

Cozzi represented the defendants in a long-running civil lawsuit that Kosowski had filed against a Dunedin medical practice where he had worked and related businesses, alleging he had been shorted thousands of dollars in billings and that his reputation as a doctor had been damaged. Prosecutors said the case, which also involved a bad online review, was heading toward a summary judgment hearing in May 2023, and that Kosowski had become obsessed with Cozzi.

According to prosecutors and the AP's account of the trial evidence, Cozzi was killed in the firm's bathroom moments after he and Kosowski took part in a conference call about the dispute. Prosecutors said Kosowski made the call from a Toyota pickup outside the office.

"This man murdered him, and he planned it out over the course of three and a half months at least," Assistant State Attorney Nathan Vonderheide said during the trial. At an October hearing, Vonderheide said Kosowski had "methodically and systematically planned out the murder of Steven Cozzi" over about 99 days.

The evidence at trial

With no body, the state built its case on video, forensic and phone evidence. As presented at trial and summarized by FOX 13 and the AP:

  • Surveillance video showed someone carrying a large box into the building shortly after 8:30 a.m. Later that morning, footage showed a person prosecutors identified as Kosowski wheeling out a heavy wagon and struggling to load it into a Toyota Tundra.
  • The truck was tracked by cameras to Kosowski's Tarpon Springs home, where investigators found it in his garage.
  • Blood and DNA: Cozzi's blood was found in the law firm's bathroom, in the truck, in Kosowski's garage and in a car Kosowski drove. Prosecutors said some of the blood in the bathroom was mixed with Kosowski's.
  • Phone records placed Kosowski's phone at the law office when Cozzi disappeared and later near a dumpster in Collier County, along the Tamiami Trail west of Miami.
  • Items at his arrest: about $280,000 in cash, masks, duct tape, firearms, brass knuckles, a vial of the paralyzing drug succinylcholine, law enforcement patches and a ballistic vest marked "EMS" that was stained with Cozzi's blood. A search of his home turned up about 200 guns, according to court documents cited by the AP.

Prosecutors also said Kosowski had been found hiding in an electrical closet at the office complex a week before Cozzi disappeared, and that he had researched Cozzi, Cozzi's home, a paralyzing medication and carts like the one used to move the body.

Investigators believe the body was left in the dumpster. A garbage truck driver who emptied it noticed an unusually "vile" smell at that stop, the AP reported. Trash from the route typically goes to a Collier County landfill that compacts its waste, and a three-day search of the landfill did not recover Cozzi's remains.

A trial without a defense

Kosowski, a Dartmouth medical school graduate who specialized in reconstructive breast surgery, waived his right to a jury and represented himself. He called no witnesses during about a week of testimony and offered no defense beyond a closing argument that prosecutors had not proved their case. Bulone took about 15 minutes to reach his verdict on Sept. 23.

Kosowski also declined to present mitigating evidence at the penalty phase. To make sure the court heard it anyway, Bulone appointed John Nohlgren, a local criminal defense attorney, as independent special counsel. Nohlgren pointed to Kosowski's lack of a criminal history, his Ivy League education, his accomplishments in medicine and his good conduct in jail over the past three years, and urged a sentence of life without parole.

At that October hearing, Kosowski did not argue for his own life. He instead accused Vonderheide of releasing recorded jail calls between him and his mother, FOX 13 reported.

How a judge alone can impose death in Florida

Most Florida death sentences follow a jury recommendation. Since a 2023 change in state law, a jury can recommend death with the votes of at least eight of 12 jurors. But a defendant may give up the right to a jury, and Kosowski did, leaving both the verdict and the sentence to the judge. In that situation, the judge decides alone whether the state has proved at least one aggravating factor beyond a reasonable doubt and then weighs the aggravating factors against any mitigating circumstances before choosing between death and life without parole. Florida law requires the judge to put those findings in writing.

What's next

Every death sentence in Florida is automatically reviewed by the Florida Supreme Court, which examines both the conviction and the sentence. With the public defender's office appointed for his appeals, Kosowski can also pursue further challenges in state and federal court, a process that typically takes years. Cozzi's family has said it will keep focusing on his memory.

Spotted an issue with this article?

Have something to say about this story?

Write us a letter

Comments

Commenting is temporarily unavailable.

No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.

Related Coverage