Back to Florida News

Prosecutors Will Seek the Death Penalty Against Man Accused of Killing Three Tourists Outside an Osceola County Vacation Rental

The Florida Press Newsroom5 min read
Prosecutors Will Seek the Death Penalty Against Man Accused of Killing Three Tourists Outside an Osceola County Vacation Rental
Photo via WKMG

Prosecutors in the Ninth Judicial Circuit have filed notice that they will seek the death penalty against Ahmad Jihad Bojeh, the 30-year-old Kissimmee man charged with killing three tourists outside an Osceola County vacation rental in January. The notice was filed Tuesday, Nov. 17, according to court documents reported by WESH and News 6 (ClickOrlando).

Bojeh faces three counts of first-degree murder. He has not been convicted and is presumed innocent. The filing sets up a capital case in a shooting that drew statewide attention because of Bojeh's history: a prior shooting in 2021 that ended in an acquittal by reason of insanity and a court-ordered conditional release that barred him from having firearms.

The victims

The three men killed were visiting Central Florida for the Mecum auto auction in Kissimmee. WESH identified them as Douglas Kraft, 68, of Columbus, Ohio; Robert Kraft, 70, of Holland, Michigan; and James Puchan, 69, of Galena, Ohio. Ages and hometowns have varied slightly across reports since January.

The men were staying at a short-term rental on Indian Point Circle near Kissimmee. Deputies said they were stuck at the property because of car trouble and were waiting outside when they were shot shortly after noon on Jan. 17.

The shooting and arrest

According to the Osceola County Sheriff's Office, investigators quickly identified Bojeh, who lived in the home next door. Deputies said he ran back to his house, where he was arrested. Sheriff Christopher Blackmon said two weapons were found inside the home. Deputies arrested him about an hour after the shooting.

According to published accounts of the arrest affidavit, the men were waiting for a replacement rental car when a neighbor walked up and shot each of them, with no reported argument beforehand. Deputies arrived within minutes and pronounced all three dead at the scene. Investigators said two pistols found in Bojeh's bedroom matched shell casings recovered outside the rental home. The affidavit describes Bojeh as uncooperative after his arrest, saying he yelled profanities and racial slurs, refused warrants for DNA and blood samples and had to be physically restrained.

Blackmon said in January that investigators had "nothing" pointing to a motive and that the killings appeared "random." No motive has been publicly established since.

Bojeh was initially charged with second-degree murder. A month after the shooting, State Attorney Monique Worrell announced that a grand jury had recommended three counts of first-degree murder. Attorney General James Uthmeier also said publicly that he wanted Bojeh prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law, Fox 35 Orlando reported.

What the death penalty notice says

Florida law requires prosecutors to file formal notice when they intend to seek a death sentence and to list the aggravating factors they plan to prove. According to News 6, the state cited three:

  • Bojeh is accused of killing multiple people.
  • The crime was "especially heinous, atrocious, or cruel."
  • The crime was committed in a "cold, calculated, and premeditated manner without any pretense of moral or legal justification."

WESH reported that the filing points to "the facts of this offense and (Bojeh's) prior record" and states that "sufficient aggravated circumstances do exist to justify the imposition of the death penalty."

The decision came later than usual. In April, prosecutors asked the judge to waive the standard 45-day deadline for the death penalty decision because defense lawyers were having trouble reaching witnesses in the Middle East, where war was keeping them from traveling to the United States, WFTV reported at the time. Both sides said they wanted to hear from those witnesses before the state decided.

If Bojeh is convicted of first-degree murder, a jury would then weigh the aggravating factors against any mitigating evidence. Under the law Florida adopted in 2023, a death recommendation requires the votes of at least eight of the 12 jurors, not a unanimous jury.

The 2021 shooting and conditional release

The case has drawn scrutiny because of Bojeh's earlier contact with the courts. In 2021, he was arrested after firing at a person and at cars in the parking lot of a Wawa gas station on U.S. 192 in Kissimmee. Court records show he was later "acquitted by reason of insanity," News 6 reported.

He was released on Dec. 20, 2022, under a conditional release plan that included outpatient mental health treatment, according to court records summarized in public accounts of the case. In August 2023, his case manager reported that he had a job and was complying with treatment. Between 2006 and 2022, the Osceola County Sheriff's Office received 41 calls to the family's home, 16 of them involving Bojeh.

A December 2022 psychological evaluation found that he did not meet the criteria for involuntary hospitalization. Circuit Judge Keith Carsten then issued a conditional release order stating that Bojeh "shall NOT own, possess, or have access to firearms or any other illegal weapons." How he came to have the two weapons deputies found in January has been a central question in the case.

Competency

Bojeh's mental fitness has been an issue since his arrest. A judge ordered a competency evaluation in February, weeks after the shooting, and the issue was the subject of further hearings in the spring. Multiple doctors evaluated him, and in September a judge ruled he was mentally fit to stand trial, according to WESH. No insanity defense has been publicly raised in the current case.

The family's call for change

In a statement signed "Kraft Family," relatives thanked Assistant State Attorney Peter Donnelly and his staff. They said the deaths were "entirely preventable" and called for legislative changes in two areas: security requirements for short-term rentals, and oversight of criminal defendants with mental health issues.

Both issues reach beyond Osceola County, a tourism-heavy county next to the Walt Disney World area where many visitors stay in rental homes. Florida's conditional release system for defendants found not guilty by reason of insanity applies statewide.

What's next

The next hearing in the case is a status hearing set for Feb. 10, 2027, according to WESH. No trial date has been set. Bojeh remains in custody.

Spotted an issue with this article?

Have something to say about this story?

Write us a letter

Comments

Commenting is temporarily unavailable.

No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.

Related Coverage