Back to Florida News

Four men charged in 2013 kidnapping and murder of Orlando man Jim Johnson Jr., Florida attorney general says

The Florida Press Newsroom5 min read
Four men charged in 2013 kidnapping and murder of Orlando man Jim Johnson Jr., Florida attorney general says
Photo via WJXT

Nearly 13 years after Jim Johnson Jr. was abducted outside an Orlando barbershop and later found dead in the woods near Daytona Beach, four men have been charged with first-degree felony murder, kidnapping and racketeering in his death, Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier announced Thursday in Orlando. Authorities allege the men operated as a criminal enterprise that kidnapped Johnson, forced him to lead them to a family home and robbed it, shooting a man inside.

The arrests come as Uthmeier's office expands a statewide cold case push launched this year, and officials framed them as proof that age alone will not close an unsolved Florida homicide. All four men are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.

Who is charged

Orlando police and the Attorney General's Office identified the four defendants as:

  • Carlton Leon Williams, 50, of Orlando
  • Nathaniel Webster, 42, of Altamonte Springs
  • Sean Quentin Daniel Cosby Davis, 35, of Orlando
  • Derrick Lineil Dean, 47, of Orlando

Each faces the same set of charges, according to the state: first-degree felony murder, kidnapping, armed kidnapping, two counts of grand theft of an automobile, armed burglary of a dwelling with assault or battery, armed robbery with a firearm, aggravated battery with a firearm, unlawful use of a two-way communication device, and racketeering.

Three of the men were taken into custody by the Orlando Police Department's fugitive unit and SWAT team, and the fourth turned himself in, according to accounts from the news conference. Officials did not say which defendant surrendered.

What happened in December 2013

According to investigators, Johnson was confronted and taken on the morning of Dec. 6, 2013, after leaving a barbershop on South Orange Blossom Trail. Witnesses told police he vanished from the back of the business around 9:15 a.m., and officers later found a large bloodstain near where his vehicle had been parked.

Investigators believe Johnson gave his abductors the address of a family home. There, authorities say, armed men forced their way inside, held a friend of Johnson's at gunpoint and shot him in the leg, then took cash and valuables from a hidden floor safe. Large amounts of blood were found throughout the house. The wounded man escaped, was treated, and later gave investigators an account of what happened. A vehicle and other property were also taken, according to officials.

Johnson's body was found Dec. 11, 2013, in a wooded area in Daytona Beach. The Volusia County medical examiner determined that he died of homicidal violence.

How investigators built the case

For about a decade, the investigation made little progress. Prosecutors said the break came from a comprehensive review of the original case file combined with new analysis: cellphone records and historical cell-site data, surveillance video, DNA work and other evidence that, they allege, documents the defendants' communications and movements before, during and after the crimes. Some of the phone records traced movement toward the Daytona Beach area where Johnson's body was found, according to officials.

Investigators concluded the group operated as a criminal enterprise across multiple counties and that its members aided one another in the felonies that ended in Johnson's death. That theory underpins both the racketeering count and the felony murder charge, which under Florida law can apply to each participant in certain violent felonies when a death results, regardless of who caused it.

Orlando Police Chief Eric Smith said the evidence showed the crime was not random. "It was a coordinated operation in which those suspects worked together to kidnap Johnson and rob him of his money and property," Smith said, according to News 6.

The case was led by the Orlando Police Department's Cold Case Homicide Unit and the Office of Statewide Prosecution's Cold Case Investigation Unit, with help from the Orange County Sheriff's Office and the Daytona Beach Police Department. Officials singled out OPD Detective Michael Fields for his work on the case, and credited Project: Cold Case, a nonprofit that profiles unsolved homicides, with referring it to the Attorney General's Office.

What officials said

Uthmeier said the defendants believed they had escaped responsibility. "They thought they could get away with it," he said, according to FOX 13. "Here in Florida, there is no expiration when it comes to justice."

In a written statement, Uthmeier said that after more than a decade, justice is finally coming for Johnson and his family, and he credited cold case detectives and partner agencies. He also told reporters that several of the defendants are tied to other crimes he described as very heinous and said the state would prosecute them to the fullest, without detailing those cases.

"To Jim Johnson Jr.'s family, we have not forgotten him, and we will never stop fighting for justice," Smith said in the state's announcement.

Ryan Backman of Project: Cold Case acknowledged the toll of the long wait. "Nothing can return Jim to his family or erase the years spent waiting for answers," he said, according to News 6.

Florida's cold case push

The arrests come about seven months after Uthmeier announced a statewide cold case initiative in April that pairs the Office of Statewide Prosecution with Othram, a forensic company that uses advanced DNA testing and genetic genealogy. At the time, his office said Florida had more than 21,000 unsolved murders since 1965, along with nearly 900 cases of unidentified human remains and about 2,500 unsolved missing persons cases. The state has put more than $600,000 toward work with Othram, according to WUSF.

The Attorney General's Office already had a Cold Case Investigations Unit, created under Uthmeier's predecessor, Ashley Moody, to assist local agencies on select cases. Officials on Thursday also cited improved electronic sharing of case files between agencies as a factor that helps older investigations move again.

For Central Florida families waiting on answers in their own unsolved cases, the message from Thursday's announcement was that agencies are reopening old files with new tools.

What's next

Special Counsel Rich Mantei of the Office of Statewide Prosecution is handling the case. Prosecutors said they plan to present it to a grand jury within about two weeks and seek indictments, though no date was announced. In Florida, a capital first-degree murder charge must be brought through a grand jury indictment. Court dates for the four defendants had not been announced as of Thursday.

Spotted an issue with this article?

Have something to say about this story?

Write us a letter

Comments

Commenting is temporarily unavailable.

No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.

Related Coverage