Orange County School Board Imposes District Health Plan in 5-3 Vote; Unions Say $66.6 Million Shifts to 20,000 Workers

The Orange County School Board voted 5-3 on Friday, Nov. 13, to impose the district's own health insurance and salary plan on roughly 20,000 school employees, rejecting a compromise from a state-appointed special magistrate that both employee unions had accepted. The unions estimate the district's plan shifts about $66.6 million in health care costs onto teachers and support staff.
Board members Angie Gallo, Anne Douglas and Stephanie Vanos voted no. The decision, made at an impasse hearing that ran for hours, imposes the district's 2026-27 terms on employees represented by the Orange Education Support Professionals Association and the Classroom Teachers Association, who have been at an impasse with Orange County Public Schools since April, Central Florida Public Media reported.
In a separate, unanimous vote, the board agreed that any unused money in the district's Disney property tax litigation account should go directly to employees as a pay supplement. No amount or payment date was set.
What the board approved
The district's position has been that its self-insured employee benefits trust cannot keep paying for coverage at current employee contribution levels. Under a self-insured trust, the district and employees pay in money that covers medical claims, and the district must keep reserves equal to 60 days of claims.
The district's proposal, as WFTV reported in September from numbers it obtained while the case was before the magistrate, would sharply raise deductibles on its two main plans. Coverage of Friday's hearing did not detail whether those figures changed in the final version:
| Plan feature | Current | District proposal | CTA counterproposal |
|---|---|---|---|
| OA Plus Hybrid family deductible | $800 | $6,000 | $1,600 |
| SureFit family deductible | $600 | $4,000 | $1,200 |
| SureFit family cost per paycheck | $266 | $588 | $293 |
CTA President Clinton McCracken told WFTV at the time that the insurance changes, combined with the district's wage proposal, "would mean an average pay cut of 7 percent for teachers who are already struggling to get by."
The district's case: a trust in deficit
OCPS attorney Jeffrey Mendel told the board the trust ran deficits in nine of the past 10 years. He said the district began drawing down reserves in 2017, and by 2019 the trust did not have enough money to cover claims while keeping its required stabilization fund.
District contributions to the trust rose from $16.9 million in 2020 to about $86 million in 2026, Mendel said, and OCPS has put roughly $1.75 billion into the trust since 2020. Even so, the district projects a $145.5 million shortfall for the current fiscal year.
Mendel blamed rising medical and prescription costs, declining enrollment in traditional public schools and what he called inadequate state funding. He said the district faced a choice between cutting staff, its largest general fund expense, or raising revenue for health insurance through higher employee contributions and coverage changes. "We have chosen the latter," he said.
Keeping employees' current coverage costs about $20 million a month, and that expense was not budgeted beyond December. Superintendent Maria Vazquez said staff were looking at options to cover December, including holding positions vacant and finding procurement savings, and said she was confident the district would find the money.
The rejected compromise
After negotiations stalled, special magistrate James W. Mastriani reviewed the dispute and issued a recommendation on Oct. 16 that split the difference on salary increases and insurance costs. Both unions accepted it. The district rejected it, arguing the recommendation would leave the insurance trust with a projected $93.7 million shortfall and create an $11.5 million salary budget deficit.
The board had been scheduled to take up the dispute Oct. 21, but that hearing was postponed after union attorney Mark Richard raised procedural objections and warned the district could face an unfair labor practice charge.
The unions push back
At Friday's hearing, the unions argued the district had not exhausted other ways to control costs before shifting them to employees. "This insurance deal is a laughingstock in the state right now," Richard said, questioning whether OCPS had adequately explored competing providers.
"Our educators spend their careers caring for other people's children," McCracken said. "They should not have to sacrifice their own family's healthcare to remain in this profession."
Brevard County School Board Chairman Matt Susin, who appeared as a witness, asked whether the district had properly evaluated an alternative for infusion care that he said could save millions of dollars.
District officials said they had met with Orlando Health several times about adding a second narrow provider network, but that Cigna told the district its contract with AdventHealth prevented another narrow network, and that pursuing one could put a $10 million reduction from AdventHealth at risk. Board member Maria Salamanca said the two sides had met 20 times during the impasse and that the union had not presented an alternative that would work for the district.
Employees describe the stakes
Much of the hearing was employee testimony. Samantha Lindstrom, a fifth-year high school math teacher, said that under the district's plan her paycheck deductions to keep her daughter insured would rise from about $70 to nearly $400 a paycheck. After her daughter, a law student in New York, fainted and needed an ambulance, Lindstrom said the current plan helped cover the costs. "I am so grateful that I had the current insurance plan," she said. Lindstrom said she has updated her resume and applied for jobs inside and outside education.
Inocencia Ramos Molinari, a 68-year-old district employee who works two jobs, told the board she already chooses between medication and other bills. "With the new plan, I have to ask, do I have the surgery or just let time take its course?" she said.
Robyn Kaminski, a fifth-grade teacher whose husband has been treated for cancer at Moffitt Cancer Center, said, "Healthcare isn't an abstract line item on a budget spreadsheet. It's a matter of life and death."
"Have mercy on all of us," said Ron Pollock, president of the Orange Education Support Professionals Association.
When the outcome became clear, one union member shouted "Shame, shame, shame." Deborah Newlan, a longtime teacher nearing retirement, said afterward that "Half of me was expecting it," and that she felt the board members "were biased, and they're just worried about the money, and not about the teachers and staff."
The Disney tax money
The unanimous second vote concerned money OCPS set aside to cover potential refunds in its property tax litigation with Disney. As cases are resolved, money the district does not need could become available. Officials discussed roughly $20 million from settled cases, with about 80 percent going to the general fund and 20 percent to capital expenses, which would leave about $16 million for the general fund. More could become available as other cases are resolved, but the final amount and timing are uncertain.
Vanos made the motion directing unused litigation funds to employees. Vazquez said a distribution could happen around January, once legal and payroll steps are complete. District officials and some board members cautioned that a one-time supplement would not solve the district's ongoing monthly insurance costs.
What's next
Salamanca, Chair Teresa Jacobs and Alicia Farrant are leaving the board, and Friday was the last meeting before new members are sworn in. The district still has to identify money to cover coverage costs in December, and the size and timing of any Disney litigation supplement remain to be set, with Vazquez pointing to January as the earliest likely date.
Spotted an issue with this article?
Have something to say about this story?
Write us a letterComments
No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.
Related Coverage

Florida Universities Move Closer to Armed Guardians as Board Weighs Mass-Casualty Training After FAMU Shooting
8h ago

Board of Governors Approves New College's $47.5 Million Borrowing Tied to USF Sarasota-Manatee Takeover; Florida Poly Gets $101 Million Housing Deal
11h ago

Florida Education Commissioner Henry Mack Pushes to Remove District Cap on School Voucher Funding
1d ago

Florida College Students Lean on Campus Food Pantries as Hunger-Free Campus Bills Stall and SNAP Stays Out of Reach
1d ago