Back to Florida News

Amendment 3 Fallout: Manatee Warns of Deep Cuts, Sarasota Reviews $200 Million in Projects, St. Johns Pauses Fire Station

The Florida Press Newsroom7 min read
Amendment 3 Fallout: Manatee Warns of Deep Cuts, Sarasota Reviews $200 Million in Projects, St. Johns Pauses Fire Station
Photo via WJXT

Less than three weeks after Florida voters approved Amendment 3, county governments along the Gulf Coast and in Northeast Florida are freezing jobs, shelving construction and warning residents that services will shrink. Manatee County commissioners say "significant reductions" are coming, Sarasota County is reviewing nine major capital projects worth more than $200 million, and St. Johns County has stopped work on a planned fire station in the fast-growing Beachwalk area.

The local moves come as Gov. Ron DeSantis, who championed the amendment, says the state needs to step in to "fix" parts of it before the tax cuts take hold on Jan. 1, 2027, and accuses some local governments of planning cuts designed to make a political point.

What Amendment 3 does

Amendment 3 passed on Nov. 3 with about 62% of the vote, according to NBC Miami's tally, clearing the 60% threshold required for constitutional amendments. It sharply expands the homestead exemption that applies to non-school property taxes, the portion of the bill that funds counties, cities and special districts.

  • For 2026, the maximum homestead exemption is $51,411, according to the Florida Department of Revenue figure cited by NBC Miami.
  • The non-school exemption rises to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028.
  • The exemption that applies to school taxes does not change, so homeowners will still pay school property taxes.
  • People who were not Florida residents by Dec. 31, 2026, must wait until their fifth year of receiving a homestead exemption to get the larger benefit.

Property taxes are the largest single source of revenue for most local governments, which is why county budget offices have been bracing for the change since before the vote.

Manatee County: frozen jobs and a paused $2 billion plan

Manatee County staff estimate the amendment will cut $63 million from county revenue in the first year and $113 million in the second, WUSF reported. Manatee voters backed the measure at 65%, above the statewide figure.

At a meeting Wednesday, commissioners learned the county had frozen 118 positions. County Administrator Charlie Bishop called the situation a "significant financial challenge" and said it would make the county leaner and more efficient. Staff are building line-item estimates of base budgets, the minimum needed to keep departments running.

The county's five-year, $2 billion capital improvement plan will be paused and reconsidered, with projects that have not broken ground most at risk. Commission Chairman Tal Siddique said new parks, libraries and extensions should stop. Commissioner Bob McCann called parks and libraries "luxury items." Commissioner George Kruse argued that capital projects can wait because each one carries future maintenance costs.

Siddique said departments will be consolidated, calling it "absolutely going to happen," but said he would not cut public safety or the Sheriff's Office. He opposed selling libraries or the recently acquired Mixon Fruit Farms property while supporting the sale of unused or planning-stage assets such as the Seafood Shack in Cortez. He also said raising fees to replace lost tax revenue would be "antithetical" to what voters wanted.

Kruse described the new environment as "fend for yourself" and suggested ending interlocal agreements with cities, such as shared landscaping and maintenance contracts. Bishop's list of options included interlocal agreements, take-home vehicles, property sales and department mergers. Utilities and part of development services may be spared because they run on enterprise funds rather than property taxes.

Commissioners voted unanimously to hold a special meeting Dec. 9 to review specific staff recommendations.

Sarasota County: nine projects under review

Sarasota County projects a revenue loss of $134 million within two years and $386.6 million within five years, according to Florida Association of Counties estimates cited by Suncoast Searchlight in a report published by WUSF. County Administrator Jonathan Lewis has paused hiring for 250 vacant positions and is sending letters to local governments, the school board, state agencies and nonprofit partners warning that county funding may be "reduced or limited." Lewis wrote that the letters are "not a guarantee of funding or service reduction."

Officials are reviewing nine major capital projects. Here is what each would cost, according to the report:

ProjectCounty costStatus or notes
Sheriff's Office headquarters expansion$84.8 millionAt least $5 million spent on design, land and engineering
Jail northeast addition$30.2 million150 to 250 beds; jail not expanded since 2002
Wellfield Park redevelopmentAt least $20 millionVenice expected to cover the other half of a $40 million-plus project
Benderson Park indoor sports complex$20 millionTourist Development Tax money; state pledged $10 million
Clerk of Courts records center$18 million27,000-square-foot office and warehouse
Longboat Key Library$13.2 millionLibrary impact fees; groundbreaking projected March 2027
Venice Fire Station 27$10.53 million34 new full-time positions needed by 2031
Sheriff's aviation hangar$4 millionAt Venice Municipal Airport
Lakewood Ranch fire station$2.24 millionNine full-time positions needed

Some projects are well along. "Some of them we are very, very, very, very far along with," Lewis said, singling out the Longboat Key Library. Jail officials have warned that without the addition they will likely need to begin sending inmates elsewhere by summer 2028. Commissioners delayed votes on the library's funding, leasing and maintenance agreements and are scheduled to discuss the full list on Dec. 15.

St. Johns County: a fire station "permanently paused"

In St. Johns County, fire officials now describe a planned station in the Beachwalk area as "permanently paused," News4JAX reported Nov. 19. The station had been expected to break ground next year and open by 2028. Plans to hire additional staff for it have not moved forward.

County Administrator Joy Andrews told commissioners the fire district that would have funded the station is expected to lose $14 million in property tax revenue by 2028 and another $27.8 million the following year. The county has held off on about $100 million in capital projects in all, a pause that began at a budget workshop before the election. Before the vote, county leaders had estimated the amendment could cost the county nearly $200 million a year.

Chris Naff, a spokesperson for St. Johns County Fire Rescue, said surrounding stations, including the Nocatee station, the station near Pine Island Road and U.S. 1, and Station 17 west of Interstate 95, will continue to serve the area, and that response times are expected to stay the same. "They're within probably about five to six miles of this area specifically," Naff said. County staff have asked commissioners to explore public engagement and other funding sources to offset the losses.

Elsewhere in the region, Flagler County Sheriff Rick Staly proposed a dedicated law enforcement tax earlier this month to offset his agency's expected Amendment 3 shortfall.

DeSantis: "malicious compliance" and a fix

Speaking at a news conference in Port Richey on Friday, DeSantis laid out what he called "things that I think need to be done." He said the state should help Florida's 32 mostly rural, fiscally constrained counties by amending an existing state funding formula, which he described as a small share of the state budget. He also proposed that the next administration offer temporary grants to local services, such as helping a police department keep a few officers. "This would not be something that would be permanent; it'd be something that gets you through," he said.

DeSantis warned that some local governments may cut their most visible services to send a message. "Unfortunately, you're going to see malicious compliance," he said, adding, "And honestly, I think it's a game."

His original plan included a fund to give local governments state grants while property taxes were phased down, but lawmakers removed it before placing the measure on the ballot. DeSantis said he wants to work with the Legislature to implement the cuts before his term ends in January, though no special session has been called. Earlier this week he also called for a taxpayer bill of rights to keep local governments from raising fees to replace lost revenue, and incoming legislative leaders have signaled they are unlikely to hold a special session before January.

What's next

The next decisions are local and close at hand. Manatee commissioners meet Dec. 9 to review staff recommendations, and Sarasota commissioners take up their project list Dec. 15. Counties will then write budgets for the 2027-28 fiscal year, the first full year under the $150,000 exemption, with the second step to $250,000 following in 2028. Whether the state offers any relief, through a revised funding formula for rural counties or temporary grants, will depend on the Legislature and the administration that takes office in January.

Spotted an issue with this article?

Have something to say about this story?

Write us a letter

Comments

Commenting is temporarily unavailable.

No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.

Related Coverage