Back to Florida News

Judge Dismisses Fake Voter Guide Charges Against St. Johns County Officials a Second Time

The Florida Press Newsroom5 min read
Judge Dismisses Fake Voter Guide Charges Against St. Johns County Officials a Second Time
Photo via Yahoo News

A judge on Thursday, Nov. 19, dismissed for a second time the criminal charges against three St. Johns County elected officials accused of helping distribute a fake Republican voter guide before the August 2024 primary, ruling that prosecutors refiled the case after the two-year statute of limitations had run out. The decision was not based on the evidence or on whether the officials were guilty, according to First Coast News.

The dismissal covers St. Johns County Commissioner Christian Whitehurst, former County Commissioner Sarah Arnold and St. Augustine Beach City Commissioner Dylan Rumrell, who also served as that city's mayor. All three had denied the allegations. A ruling on the charges against political consultant Brianna Jordan, the alleged organizer, is still pending.

Why the case was dismissed

Circuit Judge William E. Davis found that the charges were time-barred, according to the St. Augustine Record. Prosecutors had two years to bring the election-law misdemeanors, and the alleged conduct took place in August 2024.

The State Attorney's Office first filed the case in July 2026, inside that window. But a judge dismissed it in October after ruling that misdemeanor charges belonged in county court, not circuit court. Prosecutors refiled in St. Johns County Court on Nov. 2, by which point more than two years had passed since the mailers went out.

The defense argued that the first filing did not stop the clock. In a Nov. 13 motion, defense attorney Hank Coxe wrote that the state's argument for extending the deadline failed because the earlier case was thrown out for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction rather than for a defect in form, the St. Augustine Record reported. Coxe also noted the new charges were nearly identical to the ones already dismissed. First Coast News reported that the judge found the refiling came just barely too late.

The state and the local Republican Party disagree with the ruling, pointing out that the original July filing fell within the statute of limitations, according to First Coast News.

What the officials were accused of

Prosecutors charged all five defendants in the case with misdemeanor conspiracy and with producing an unauthorized voter guide under Florida Statute 106.1436, according to News4JAX. Jordan, described as a campaign manager and political consultant, was also charged with felony tampering with physical evidence. A fifth defendant, identified by News4JAX as Jamie Johnson, faced the same two misdemeanors.

According to charging documents described by News4JAX and Action News Jax, the group worked between Aug. 1 and Aug. 15, 2024, to produce and mail a voter guide that presented itself as an official publication of the St. Johns County Republican Executive Committee. Prosecutors said the committee never authorized it and that the guide listed candidates the party had not endorsed, including Whitehurst, while omitting the disclosures state law requires on political advertising.

An affidavit described an envelope-stuffing operation at a St. Augustine home used as a campaign headquarters, Action News Jax reported, with roughly $25,000 in postal purchases and between 10,000 and 30,000 guides prepared. The envelopes carried no return address and were mailed from post offices in Jacksonville and Orlando, which investigators said showed an effort to hide where they came from. The Florida Department of Law Enforcement investigated.

Whitehurst narrowly defeated Anne-Marie Evans in that 2024 Republican primary, according to First Coast News.

How the case unfolded

The case has moved through several courts and rulings in just over four months. Key dates are below.

DateDevelopment
Aug. 1 to 15, 2024Period when the guides were allegedly produced and mailed
July 2026Five defendants charged in circuit court after FDLE probe
July 21, 2026County Commission approves no-confidence vote, 3-2
Early October 2026Misdemeanors dismissed as filed in the wrong court
Oct. 16, 2026Felony tampering count against Jordan dismissed with prejudice
Nov. 2, 2026Prosecutors refile misdemeanors in county court
Nov. 19, 2026Charges against the three officials dismissed as time-barred

In the October tampering ruling, the judge found that the affidavit's claim that Jordan burned some of the guides did not establish destruction of evidence, because the guides had already been mailed, many were recovered by law enforcement and hundreds of copies remained available, News4JAX reported. The judge rejected Jordan's other arguments, including constitutional challenges to the voter guide law and claims of selective prosecution.

Political fallout in St. Johns County

The charges shook county government over the summer. On July 21, the St. Johns County Commission approved a no-confidence vote in its two charged colleagues by a 3-2 margin, with Arnold and Whitehurst voting no, according to Action News Jax. A letter dated July 23 and signed by Commission Chair Clay Murphy and Vice Chair Ann Taylor asked Gov. Ron DeSantis to suspend the two commissioners while the charges were pending. Neither was removed, and both continued to serve.

Arnold did not seek reelection and has since left office. Whitehurst remains on the commission, and Rumrell remains on the St. Augustine Beach commission.

Reaction

The legal team for the three officials welcomed the ruling. In a statement reported by News4JAX and Action News Jax, the team said: These charges have been dismissed for the second time. It added: This investigation was a disappointing waste of taxpayer resources and we are glad to be able to move forward.

Denver Cook, chair of the St. Johns County Republican Party, whose organization produced the genuine 2024 voter guide and first raised alarms about the copycat mailer, sharply criticized the outcome. First Coast News quoted him: It's just disgusting that election officials can commit fraud and have no accountability. None of the officials has been convicted, and the dismissal leaves the allegations unproven in court.

Evans, the candidate Whitehurst beat in the primary, told First Coast News she was disappointed and does not believe the case has reached the end of the road.

What's next

The judge took Jordan's motion to dismiss her remaining misdemeanor charges under advisement and will rule later, News4JAX reported. The status of Johnson's charges was not detailed in reports on Thursday's ruling.

Whether prosecutors will appeal the dismissal had not been announced as of Friday. Unless an appellate court revives the case, the three officials will not stand trial on the voter guide charges.

Spotted an issue with this article?

Have something to say about this story?

Write us a letter

Comments

Commenting is temporarily unavailable.

No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.

Related Coverage