Bradenton's Saint Stephen's Episcopal School Disputes Attorney General Uthmeier's Expulsion and Tuition Claims

Saint Stephen's Episcopal School in Bradenton is pushing back against Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier, who has accused the private school of expelling students after their parents objected to classroom readings and then trying to keep the families' tuition. In a message to parents and staff, Head of School Peter Kraft said the students "were not expelled" and called the tuition claims false, while promising the school will "cooperate fully" with the attorney general's office, which has demanded a response by Nov. 30.
Uthmeier says the school may have violated Florida's Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act by misleading families about what their children would be taught. His office has not called the matter a formal investigation and has not filed a lawsuit, Fox 13 reported.
What the attorney general alleges
In a five-page letter to Kraft sent the week of Nov. 9, Uthmeier wrote that the school removed children from multiple families after their parents complained, through the school's own process, about instructional material that the parents "apparently considered sexually mature and containing LGBTQ-related content," the Sarasota Herald-Tribune reported. According to the letter, school officials had told parents the "curriculum was free of LGBTQ-related instructional material."
The letter says that after the complaints, the school terminated the students' enrollment, citing its Standards of Civility policy, and intended to keep the full year of tuition the families had paid. Uthmeier pointed to the school's enrollment contract, which makes parents liable for a full year's tuition and fees, or any unpaid balance, if a student withdraws voluntarily or involuntarily. Tuition and fees for a seventh grader total $31,900 a year, according to the school's website as cited by the Herald-Tribune.
The complaints were relayed to the attorney general's Office of Parental Rights, which is reviewing the matter. The families also allege the school withheld their children's transcripts, Fox 13 reported. The families and students have not been publicly identified, and the parents have not commented publicly.
The four readings
The letter lists four works the attorney general says contain sexually mature material assigned to middle school students:
- "The Poet X" by Elizabeth Acevedo
- "Girl" by Jamaica Kincaid
- "Annie John" by Jamaica Kincaid
- "Answers in the Pages" by David Levithan
Uthmeier said the readings touch on both heterosexual and same-sex sexuality, and Fox 13 reported that the letter describes passages involving sexual encounters between teenagers. He noted that the school's handbook prohibits pornography and obscene material on campus and wrote that, "under any reasonable reading, these materials contain the very kind of sexually explicit" content the handbook forbids, according to the Herald-Tribune.
What the state is demanding
The letter directs the school to preserve all records related to the dispute, stop trying to collect tuition from the affected families, stop withholding the children's records, and "make these families whole." The school must respond in writing by Nov. 30.
Uthmeier took the dispute public on Nov. 12 with a video on X in which he said, "Schools cannot mislead families about their curriculum." He returned to it on Monday, Nov. 16, after a Tampa news conference on fentanyl trafficking arrests. "We've had a lot of concerns with this one establishment, where we see very harmful sexual content in young grade levels," he said. "That can't happen. So we're going to take action." He said the state has "broad consumer protection tools" it could use, WUSF reported.
Because Saint Stephen's is a private school, the attorney general is framing the dispute as a consumer protection matter, focused on whether the school delivered the education families paid for and described it accurately, according to ABC7 Sarasota.
The school's response
Saint Stephen's first responded with a brief statement saying it will cooperate fully with the attorney general's office, is "confident we have acted ethically and in accordance with our educational values, policies, and Florida law," and looks forward to providing "the facts and documentation" the office requested.
Kraft went further in an email to parents and staff that was published by The Bradenton Journal and reported by WUSF. He disputed what he called "several inaccurate assertions" by Uthmeier and the media. The students "were not expelled," he wrote; instead, their families were separated from the school for "repeated and serious violations of our Civility Clause."
Kraft said the school's board acted after several incidents that went beyond the parents' concerns about the middle school literature, which he said contains no sexually explicit material. He wrote that the school has a longstanding policy allowing students and families to request alternative assignments when they object to a book or other material.
On tuition, Kraft said the attorney general's account is false. He wrote that the families' monthly payments stopped after their separation date and that any credits were refunded.
About the school
Saint Stephen's, founded in 1970, is an independent college preparatory day school affiliated with the Episcopal Church, serving students from age 3 through 12th grade on a 35-acre campus in Bradenton. It enrolls roughly 650 students and is accredited by the Florida Council of Independent Schools.
A pattern of interventions
The Bradenton dispute is the second recent case in which Uthmeier has stepped into a classroom controversy on the Suncoast. He previously called for a teacher's removal at Pine View School in Sarasota County, and that teacher now faces state disciplinary action, WUSF reported. In both cases, he posted on social media at nearly the same time his office took action, according to the Herald-Tribune.
Uthmeier, appointed attorney general by Gov. Ron DeSantis in 2025 to succeed Ashley Moody, won a full term on Nov. 3, defeating Democrat José Javier Rodríguez by less than 2 percentage points.
What's next
The school's written response is due to the attorney general's office by Nov. 30. Kraft has said Saint Stephen's will provide documents and information as requested. What the office does next, whether it drops the matter, negotiates a resolution with the families or opens a formal action under the deceptive practices law, will likely depend on that response. Uthmeier has not said what remedy he would seek beyond the demands in his letter.
Spotted an issue with this article?
Have something to say about this story?
Write us a letterComments
No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.
Related Coverage

Florida School Board Members Say State Pressure Is Silencing Them, Researchers Report
21h ago

Byron and Erika Donalds Pitch 'Accountability' for Public and Choice Schools Alike as Florida's Voucher Tracking Problems Linger
1d ago

Board of Governors Chair Asks Florida Universities to Keep H-1B Hiring Freeze Past Jan. 5 While the State Reviews Data
1d ago

Orange County School Board Imposes District Health Plan in 5-3 Vote; Unions Say $66.6 Million Shifts to 20,000 Workers
1d ago