Back to Florida News

Byron and Erika Donalds Pitch 'Accountability' for Public and Choice Schools Alike as Florida's Voucher Tracking Problems Linger

The Florida Press Newsroom5 min read
Byron and Erika Donalds Pitch 'Accountability' for Public and Choice Schools Alike as Florida's Voucher Tracking Problems Linger
Photo via WUSF

Governor-elect Byron Donalds and his wife, school choice advocate Erika Donalds, told an education technology showcase in Hollywood on Friday, Nov. 13, that the incoming administration will stop sorting schools by type and focus on how students and institutions perform, with "accountability" applying to public schools and the private and charter options that receive state money.

The remarks, reported by the Florida Phoenix and republished by WUSF and WLRN, offer the clearest preview yet of how Donalds, who takes office Jan. 5, intends to manage Florida's universal school choice system. They come as private schools receiving vouchers still face fewer financial and testing requirements than public schools, and as a state audit has questioned whether the money is reaching the right schools.

What the Donaldses said

The governor-elect said his administration will set aside labels for school types. "I'm agnostic on the school. I'm much more focused on the outcomes for our students," he said, according to the Florida Phoenix.

Erika Donalds called for a new way of describing Florida's schools. She said the state should treat public, private, charter, homeschool and hybrid options as a single "education freedom economy," and that the next administration would try to align funding, student counting, assessments, accountability and transparency across all of them. "We have to completely change the way that we communicate about schools and students in our state," she said, according to the Phoenix.

On artificial intelligence, a central theme of the showcase, the governor-elect said technology can make teachers more efficient but should not replace them. "My personal belief is that you have to have an adult human being in the classroom," he said.

The event

The showcase was hosted by LaunchEd Group and drew small vendors and education companies, some worth billions of dollars, the Phoenix reported. Students pitched startups to investors, and at least six companies sought contracts from school leaders in attendance.

Others who spoke included Education Commissioner Henry Mack, Charter Schools USA CEO Jon Hage, Miami-Dade School Board member Roberto Alonso and Sen. Don Gaetz, R-Crestview. Hage told the audience there are no silver bullets in education. Gaetz, who has pushed to overhaul how voucher money flows, said, "Whatever can go wrong with this system has gone wrong."

The accountability gap

The emphasis on accountability matters because the rules differ sharply by school type. Private schools that receive state scholarship money are not subject to public meeting laws, are not required to publish their budgets and are not run by elected officials, the Phoenix noted. Public dollars for private school students are not tied to standardized test scores, and many private school students do not take the state's FAST exams, which makes direct comparisons with public schools difficult.

More than 500,000 students participate in Florida's school choice programs, according to EdChoice figures cited in an analysis republished by WLRN in July. The scholarships are open to any K-12 student regardless of income and are worth roughly $9,000 a year per student.

A November 2025 operational audit by the Florida Auditor General found the Department of Education could not tell which schools, if any, more than 30,000 scholarship students attended, and that about $270 million could not be accurately tied to the correct school or program. Public and private schools both complained that payments arrived late. The Legislature did not fix the funding system in its 2026 session because the House and Senate could not agree on a bill, though Gaetz's proposal passed the Senate early in the session.

Alonso said private schools should share information. "People are understanding that some level of accountability has to be put in place," he told the Phoenix.

Where Mack stands

Mack, appointed commissioner by the State Board of Education in July, told the Phoenix he wants insight into how scholarship students perform. "I'm not going to bind [private schools] to anything, other than I'm asking to know how their students are performing," he said. He said tying voucher eligibility to transparency "could be an option" but deferred to the governor-elect and the Legislature.

Mack is separately pushing to remove the district-level cap on voucher spending in the state's school funding formula, a change that could leave some districts more dependent on discretionary money controlled by the Department of Education. No bill had been filed as of last week, according to WLRN.

The Donaldses' record on school choice

Both Donaldses have long been central figures in Florida's school choice movement. As a state lawmaker, Byron Donalds shepherded the bill that created the Hope Scholarship, a precursor to the universal voucher program, and co-sponsored a law allowing charter schools to operate inside traditional public school buildings, according to earlier reporting by the Florida Phoenix.

Erika Donalds won a seat on the Collier County School Board in 2014 and later left, saying she was frustrated by her inability to make change as a board member. She helped open Mason Classical Academy, a Hillsdale College-affiliated charter school in Naples, founded the for-profit charter management companies OptimaEd and Optima Management Solutions, and founded the Education Freedom Foundation, which advocates for school choice. She owns a virtual reality education company. A Florida Bulldog analysis found her companies have received millions in management contracts from taxpayer-funded charter schools; she has said in a statement that she does not do business with the state of Florida and never has.

The couple has said they want to "break the public school monopoly" and put parents, rather than government, in charge of their children's education. Their stated goals have included AI-driven learning, changes to standardized testing and the A-F school grading system, and individualized plans for every student.

What it means for Florida families

For public school districts, the Donaldses' message signals that the next administration will not slow the growth of choice programs. For private schools taking scholarships, the talk of aligning assessments and transparency suggests possible new reporting requirements, though neither the governor-elect nor his wife offered specifics on Friday, and Mack said he would not bind private schools to anything beyond reporting performance.

Schools are also preparing for a new artificial intelligence policy that takes effect in July for universities and K-12 schools, the Phoenix reported. Under it, local school boards must require parents to opt in before their children use AI at school.

What's next

Donalds takes office Jan. 5. The 2027 legislative session will be the first test of whether his administration and the new legislative leaders, Senate President Jim Boyd and House Speaker Sam Garrison, can agree on a fix for scholarship funding that the House and Senate could not settle this year, and whether that fix includes testing or transparency requirements for private schools that take state money.

Spotted an issue with this article?

Have something to say about this story?

Write us a letter

Comments

Commenting is temporarily unavailable.

No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.

Related Coverage